Join | Login


  Home > Essays > Articles > God is Not Great (book review)
Essays Articles
  1. Unforgettable Moments in Life
  2. Vituperative Recriminations
  3. Of Conspiracies, Terrorists, War and Econo
  4. Abortion?
  5. Earth Day 2015--Promises To Be Kept
  6. Science Trumps Belief
  7. Death by Dishonor
  8. Environmental Greenies Are Very Dangerous
  9. Coal: Energy and Pain in Eastern Kentucky
  10. A Meaningful Life
  11. Obama, a Modern Caesar?
  12. Change is Good
  13. Wall Street Protesters Don't Value America
  14. You Should Write a Book
  15. Boredom Can Kill
  16. Behold, the Wretched Refuse of Our Teeming
  17. Democrats Plumb New Lower Depths
  18. Atheist/Agnostics Embrace Church Meetings
  19. Fiscal Sanity v. the Big Lie
  20. I'm Afraid to Write!

Featured Book
Einstein, Religion, Politics and Literature-461 pps
by Lonnie Hicks

A look at the United States in terms of the major institutions in the country and the role they play in American life. Based on real time blogs, this book is a collection..  
BookAds by Silver
Gold and Platinum Members

God is Not Great (book review)
By David A. Schwinghammer   

Share    Print  Save   Author Tracker

Christopher Hitchens did not convert on
his death bed.

Recently deceased Christopher Hitchens was the best of the trio of best-selling agnostics and atheist writers. The title GOD IS NOT GREAT is a parody of the terrorists’ invocation “Allahu Akbar” (God is great) supposedly screamed when they crashed 747s into the Trade Center buildings.

Hitchens saves most of his ammunition for radical Islam. Mainly he argues they’re nothing but a bunch of copycats, going so far as to ban the eating of pork. Muhammad also reportedly used the Bible as an inspiration for the Qur’an and many of his hadiths. Hitchens also isn’t fond of the torture they put women through, mainly the mutilation of sexual organs and the sewing shut of the vagina, leaving only a small aperture for menstruating and urinating. Especially grating is the revelation that many of the terrorists who attacked the Twin Towers were virgins (having been isolated from women for most of their lives), and that their express motivation was martyrdom for the cause for which they would be rewarded with 70 virgins in the afterlife. Of course the Jewish custom of circumcision (adopted by Christians) also gets its share of derision. Perhaps Hitchens’ best argument here is his belittling of Intelligent Design. If God is so great, why do rabbis need to improve on his work?

Perhaps Hitchens second most derided belief is Catholicism. He especially reviles Pope Pius XII’s appeasement of the Nazis and the church’s later help in helping some of them escape. The Inquisition is touched upon only briefly, but the church’s treatment of Galileo is especially condemned.

Hitchens doesn’t have much respect for scientists and philosophers who hedge their bets. In the early stages of ORIGIN OF THE SPECIES, Charles Darwin tiptoed around the idea of nature being the sole source of human life. Other philosophers and scientists leave room for the possibility that a supreme being created evolution. Hitchens scoffs at the idea as being unnecessarily intricate. Evolution is a sloppy process with remnants of previous existence still around, such as a tail in humans. According to Hitchens the human eye is backwards. An all powerful God wouldn’t make that mistake.

Hitchens can be as vicious as Don Rickles. Here’s what he has to say about Tim LaHaye, who along with Jerry B. Jenkins, wrote the LEFT BEHIND series about the End Times and The Rapture. He says it was “apparently generated by the old expedient of letting two orangutans loose on a word processor.” Hitchens insists that religion “is not just amoral but positively immoral,” primarily for the hell it puts children through. He outlines five areas in which this is true:

1. Presenting a false picture of the world to the innocent and the credulous.
2. The doctrine of blood sacrifice.
3. The doctrine of atonement. (Atonement for what? Should a child be blamed for what his parents did?)
4. The doctrine of eternal reward and/or punishment.
5. The imposition of impossible tasks and rules.

Hitchens, as does Freud, cites fear of death and wishful thinking as the reason most people cling to religion. He also argues that for a group of people who emphasize faith they sure don’t have much. Muslims are outraged by cartoons making fun of Muhammad. Scientists are portrayed as converting on their death beds. Darwin was supposed to be perusing a Bible. He wasn’t. Einstein made it clear once and for all that he did not believe in God: “It was, of course, a lie what you read about my religious convictions, a lie which is being systematically repeated. I do not believe in a personal God and I have never denied this but expressed it clearly. If something is in me which can be called religious then it is the unbounded admiration for the structure of the world so far as science can reveal it.”

Christopher Hitchens never ducked a debate with a religious proponent and usually came out ahead. Richard Dawkins adds a blurb to the front of the book: “If you are a religious apologist invited to debate with Christopher Hitchens, decline.” And no, Hitchens did not convert on his deathbed.

Click here to post or read comments.

Recent articles by this author.     All articles by this author
  • The Wilderness of Ruin, book review (Tuesday, April 21, 2015)
  • A Beautiful Mind, book review (Wednesday, April 01, 2015)
  • Another Planet, book review (Thursday, March 05, 2015)
  • The Three Stooges, book review (Tuesday, February 10, 2015)
  • The God Particle (Tuesday, January 20, 2015)
  • Empire of Sin, book review (Wednesday, January 07, 2015)
  • Science at the Edge, book review (Wednesday, December 17, 2014)
  • Obama, a Modern Caesar? (Tuesday, December 02, 2014)

  • Super Nutrition for Dogs n' Cats by Nina Anderson

    Dogs can live until 20 and cats until 30. Why are their lifespans shortened? Discover natural treatments and lifestyles that can help your pet live long and prosper...  
    Featured BookAds by Silver
    Gold and Platinum Members

    RAM: Random Articles and Manuscripts by Jay Dubya

    RAM: Random Articles and Manuscripts, a non-fiction collection of 38 stories and essays, is author Jay Dubya's 32nd book...  
    Featured BookAds by Silver
    Gold and Platinum Members

    The Obama Chronicles: Stories From the Heartland by Lonnie Hicks

    This is a book done "real time" which traces the rise of Obama, written from the perspective of his political values and background. It goes on to predict how he will govern as pre..  
    Featured BookAds by Silver
    Gold and Platinum Members

    Authors alphabetically: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

    Featured Authors | New to AuthorsDen? | Add AuthorsDen to your Site
    Share AD with your friends | Need Help? | About us

    Problem with this page?   Report it to AuthorsDen
    © AuthorsDen, Inc. All rights reserved.