The Photo that Started it All
edited: Thursday, August 17, 2006
By Susan K. de Vegter
Rated "PG" by the Author.
Posted: Thursday, August 17, 2006
Become a Fan
On the day the Intafada broke out, Tuvia Grossman was riding a taxi to visit the Western Wall. He was unwittingly thrust into the international limelight -- and nearly killed in the process.
Updated May 2002
On September 30, 2000, The New York Times, Associated Press and other major media outlets published a photo of a young man -- bloodied and battered -- crouching beneath a club-wielding Israeli policeman. The caption identified him as a Palestinian victim of the recent riots -- with the clear implication that the Israeli soldier is the one who beat him.
The victim's true identity was revealed when Dr. Aaron Grossman of Chicago sent the following letter to the Times:
Regarding your picture on page A5 of the Israeli soldier and the Palestinian on the Temple Mount -- that Palestinian is actually my son, Tuvia Grossman, a Jewish student from Chicago. He, and two of his friends, were pulled from their taxicab while traveling in Jerusalem, by a mob of Palestinian Arabs, and were severely beaten and stabbed.
That picture could not have been taken on the Temple Mount because there are no gas stations on the Temple Mount and certainly none with Hebrew lettering, like the one clearly seen behind the Israeli soldier attempting to protect my son from the mob.
In response, the New York Times published a half-hearted correction which identified Tuvia Grossman as "an American student in Israel" -- not as a Jew who was beaten by Arabs. The "correction" also noted that "Mr. Grossman was wounded" in "Jerusalem's Old City" -- although the beating actually occurred in the Arab neighborhood of Wadi al Joz, not in the Old City.
In response to public outrage at the original error and the inadequate correction, The New York Times reprinted Tuvia Grossman's picture -- this time with the proper caption -- along with a full article detailing his near-lynching at the hands of Palestinians rioters.
Read Tuvia Grossman's in-depth, first-person account of his ordeal, entitled Victim of the Media War. www.aish.com/jewishissues/israeldiary/
The photo of a bloodied Tuvia Grossman became a symbol in the struggle to ensure that Israel receives the fair media coverage that every nation deserves.
In April 2002, a District Court in Paris ordered the French daily newspaper "Liberation" and the Associated Press to pay damages to Grossman in the amount of 4,500 Euro.
The Court condemned the Associated Press for "mispresenting [Grossman] as a member of the Palestinian community," while the court censured "Liberation" for "publishing the litigious picture with a comment edited the same faulty way, giving the picture a meaning and a scope it could not have."
===== ARAB ABUSE =====
Even more remarkable is that Arab groups have adopted Grossman's photo to use in their own propaganda campaigns, cynically using a bloodied Jew as a symbol of the Palestinian struggle.
An official Egyptian government website is using the Grossman photo on its "Photo Gallery".
And the Palestinian Information Center, www.islam.net, incorporated Tuvia's photo onto its homepage banner, (The graphic was recently removed from the site, but is reprinted here:)
Additionally, some Arab groups have called for a boycott of Coca-Cola, for doing business with Israel, and have circulated a series of posters to state their case. One poster shows Grossman's bleeding face juxtaposed with the Coca-Cola logo, and the tag line: "By supporting American products, you're supporting Israel."
Snopes.com reports that, ironically, since Ramallah is home to a Coca-Cola bottling facility that employs about 400 local residents (and indirectly creates employment for hundreds more), and Coca-Cola industries throughout the Middle East are operated as local businesses, any boycott of Coca-Cola in Middle Eastern countries is likely to cause more monetary harm to Arabs and Palestinians than it is to Americans or Israelis.
Snopes.com notes another irony: Pepsi is also on the Arab boycott list, with claims that the name "Pepsi" is an acronym for 'Pay Every Penny to Save Israel' or 'Pay Every Penny to the State of Israel.' As the Associated Press once noted, "Calling Pepsi a 'Jewish product' is ironic, given that Pepsi was one of many multinationals that wouldn't do business in Israel during the 40-year Arab commercial boycott of the Jewish state."
And of course the biggest irony of all is that the image chosen in the poster to represent Palestinian suffering was that of none other than Tuvia Grossman, who was nearly beaten to death by a Palestinian mob.
Click here to see the Grossman poster.
Update: Tuvia Grossman makes Aliyah to Israel.
Want to review or comment on this article?
Click here to login!
Need a FREE Reader Membership?
Click here for your Membership!
|Reviewed by Elizabeth Taylor (Reader)
|Agree with Jerry and Peter, but go a step further. Level the mid-east to sanitize the DNA and let God start over again.
|Reviewed by Peter Paton
I believe Jerry has hit the nail on the head below !
|Reviewed by Felix Perry
|Interesting write Susan with lots of important information included.
|Reviewed by ronald genise
|Don't know who is worse, those who fabercate the lies or those like the NY Times who exploit them. Even when exposed, neither will accept the truth. Of late the Forth Estate needs to be taken to task about reporting the news , not making it.
|Reviewed by George Carroll
|We are living in a world of lies,deceit and deception. I have no faith in the media in America as it has sold its soul to one party and will use any means necessary to achieve its goal as will the muslims against the jews.|
|Reviewed by Dove JoAnne Cromp (Reader)
|Oh my GOD I am TICKED OFF MAJOR!!!!! God, no wonder mankind struggles to get along.. Jesus!! As long as there is an earth mankind refuses to put his sorry ego aside.. That makes me FURIOUS!!!!!!!!!!
GOD HELP US...It is a major call for the prayer partners.. I am so angry I could spit nails.. I know our heavenly Father WEEPS and weeps as He walks city streets all over the world.. Prayers are needed.. I was fasting and praying for Israel.. So much more has to be done.. There is an old saying that man is afraid of the light that we are all born with so out of that fear creates war.. I will powerfully pray tonight dear Susan.. I feel the Lord is leading us to group together to pray for world suffering and events that need breakthrough...Prayer and fasting go hand and hand and I just eat veggies and drink fruit juice.. Heightens my sensation to the divine.. Anyway, thanks for writing this. .I am outraged and I see I am going to have to fast again for a few days while in prayer.. Hope all is well with your mom.. She is still in my prayers
Peace & Love, Dove
|Reviewed by Jerry Bolton (Reader)
|I can only say one thing about all of it, including many other things . . . Damn bastards . . . Why do so many people believe the f**king lies?|