Join | Login  

     Popular! Books, Stories, Articles, Poetry
Where Authors and Readers come together!


Featured Authors:  Temple Williams, inancy rossman, iElisabeth Barstowe, iKeith Rowley, iEdmond Humm, iJanice Scott, iMaryanne Raphael, i

  Home > Education/Training > Articles Popular: Books, Stories, Articles, Poetry     

Leslie P Garcia

· Become a Fan
· Contact me
· Books
· Articles
· Poetry
· News
· Stories
· Blog
· Messages
· 87 Titles
· 199 Reviews
· Save to My Library
· Share with Friends!
Member Since: Aug, 2001

Leslie P Garcia, click here to update your pages on AuthorsDen.

Featured Book
The Butterfly Effect
by Graham whittaker

The exciting new stand alone novel in the Kosovo series. Available in July 2013...  
BookAds by Silver
Gold and Platinum Members

Featured Book
Ignite the Passions Kindle Edition
by Deborah Jones

BookAds by Silver
Gold and Platinum Members

   Recent articles by
Leslie P Garcia

Life After Death by Lillie J. Roberts: A Review
Reaching the Unattainable
A Review: Firefly Run by Trish Milburn
Highlander's Bride by Deborah Gafford
Come Back to Me by Melissa Foster
Invitation to Ruin by Bronwen Evans
Midnight Sun by MJ Fredrick
Less than Demonic: an Opinion on Joe Paterno
Surrender by Jean Brashear
Unintended Consequences? The Casey Anthony Verdict
Do or Die: Atlanta and Standardized Testing
Why Teachers Whine: Performance?
           >> View all

A Nation of Test Takers?
by Leslie P Garcia   
Rated "G" by the Author.
Last edited: Thursday, March 18, 2010
Posted: Sunday, September 12, 2004

Share    Print   Save    Become a Fan

Is testing in the name of "accountability" killing our kids' interest in school?

Is it killing our teachers?

Stopping the monster...

 My first graders start their fifth week of school tomorrow. They also start their fifth week of “assessments”.

Language tests have been administered individually--although the students were given the same test at the end of Kinder.   District “benchmarks" were given, although arguably, students hadn't progressed much yet--especially since testing took the place of teaching.  Then, there was DRA,” a newly-purchased, bulky, time-consuming, costly “reading inventory” that duplicated other tests, such as the state-mandated test we start the sixth week of school.

Mind you, these students are six year olds—and all of their school experience to date, except for fire drills, has been testing.

Sadly, there is such a huge amount of money in test-producing and test-scoring companies, and such misinformation being spoonfed to politicos, that there seems little hope of bringing sanity back to public schools. Sanity as in—give teachers time to teach. Then kids pass anyway.

The original idea of standardized testing was to insure that children who graduated could read and write. But because schools threw everything into improving test scores, the field of “beating” state-mandated tests erupted into a money-consuming beast, and in-services, at least in my district, tend to be sales pitches for new “strategies” that basically are intended to insure students pass tests, whether they have the necessary skills or not.

Many will argue with me—all the testing materials companies, many administrators who know their schools’ performance is tied to these artificial performance assessments, and many politicians. I doubt many teachers will disagree, if given the assurance of protection from retaliation, and I suspect, too, that many parents and students will also agree that testing has become the be-all of schools. Defenders of the test-to-death practices currently in vogue will tick off a list of problems in the public schools, and end with their pet word, accountability.

How do you hold teachers accountable, though, who spend five out of five weeks testing, and none of those five weeks teaching? The problems in public school, frankly, are due more to the collapse of a values system than anything else. That stand is not popular, nor politically correct, but it is true . I have had first graders ask me how often I “do it” with my husband, I have had first graders so traumatized by abuse at home that they are unable to function in school, I have had first graders come to school with razor blades. None of these problems will be solved by testing—unless we start testing parents and society as a whole.

So forget “excuses,” as the politicians label such truths. Hold me accountable, even for abused kids and kids with razor blades. I’m not afraid of responsibility or of “accountability.” But unless you give me time to teach, then hold me accountable only for the hours of paperwork and “analysis” of tests, because it’s hypocritical and futile to hold me accountable for instruction I’m not allowed to give.

Our district gave us a “big” pay raise this year, added half an hour to our day, and demanded that we meet our staff development requirements through unpaid Saturday “trainings”—many of which will be sales pitches by ex-teachers who got out of the classroom to avoid testing. Yet many of my colleagues who have discussed leaving aren’t leaving because of the low salaries and the countless hours of unpaid work. They’re leaving, quite simply, because “assessment” is sapping the life out of public education.

Statistics about teachers leaving the field will grow, and the sad incidents of teachers dying on the job—through violence, occasionally, and stress-related illnesses more frequently—will be murmured through the rank and file of dedicated teachers who stay, but aren’t sure why.

Teachers who speak out against the overkill of assessment will continue to be branded troublemakers, negative people who gripe constantly. And until voters take politicians and school administrators to task, the tests will continue to choke the life out of our school systems and our kids.

I have four "personal" kids. They all graduated with honors from their high school, two of them very near the top—11th and 5th, respectively, in fairly large classes. They did fine on the state-mandated tests, thank you. But they struggled mightily in college. Why? Easy. Neither college nor life hands you questions with four multiple choice answers that require only a knowledge of certain strategies, but little thinking or global perception.

Accountability should be demanded—but should be based on occasional, perhaps randomly administered tests. And all students, but especially the early primary grades, should be taught more than tested—and tested not competitively, but analytically, so that weaknesses can be addressed.

None of these changes will come about, though, with so much money encouraging testing and “beat the test” mentalities.

Parents—if your children are spending more time on “benchmarks” and “assessments” than on education, please speak up. Educators—the administrators have to listen eventually. I consider myself a teacher, not a tester. At least—I did once. None of us should leave children behind, with or without acts of Congress. And all of us should be willing to be held accountable—if we are given the time we need to teach.

Reader Reviews for "A Nation of Test Takers?"

Want to review or comment on this article?
Click here to login!

Need a FREE Reader Membership?
Click here for your Membership!

Reviewed by Edward Saint-Ivan 5/1/2005
I really, really, enjoyed your artice. I have mixed feelings about high steaks testing.
Children need to be literate. I totally agree with the idea behind President Bush's "No Child Left Behind".
On the other hand, 99% of grade school subjects revolve around getting ready for college ie Chemistry, History, Algebra, Spanish, etc.
To say that a student needs Shakespere to be literate is totally ludocrous!
We are preparing students for the SAT who might never go to college. High School should be more than the first step toward college!
Reviewed by Regina Pounds 9/13/2004
Leslie, bravo for speaking out against one of the many non-sensical methods of control this country has been flooded with...stifling, all of it. Well-meant perhaps by some, but ultimately damaging.

I admire your courage and thank you for your concern and your work.

Reviewed by m j hollingshead 9/13/2004
well done, my sis who still teaches in California says she is either testing, getting ready to test or checking a test. Not sure when she is supposed to be teaching!

I'm glad I no longer teach... hmmm, maybe that is; no longer spend time in the classroom since many teachers are spending lots of time testing and little time teaching
Reviewed by Phyllis Jean Green 9/12/2004
Timely, beautifully-written and thought-provoking!! Overall,
I could not agree more. Hard to stop with that. SO many
vitally important issues affecting our teachers and children, one
hardly knows where to start! Rest I will try to get into an AD
message soon. Meantime, b r a v a, b r a v a,
b r a v a ~ ! ! ! Phyllis <3

The Reel Deal: Writing about Movies by Betty Jo Tucker

"The Reel Deal: Writing about Movies" is designed for people who want to learn various techniques for writing movie reviews as well as for interviewing actors, directors, screenwri..  
Featured BookAds by Silver
Gold and Platinum Members

PR Basics in a Connected World by Ann Streetman

A good overview of basics in PR for newcomers or a brief refresher for people returning to the job market...  
Featured BookAds by Silver
Gold and Platinum Members

Authors alphabetically: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Featured Authors | New to AuthorsDen? | Add AuthorsDen to your Site
Share AD with your friends | Need Help? | About us

Problem with this page?   Report it to AuthorsDen
AuthorsDen, Inc. All rights reserved.