Join (Free!) | Login  

     Popular! Books, Stories, Articles, Poetry
   Services MarketPlace (Free to post!)
Where Authors and Readers come together!


Featured Authors:  Christina Neely, iLinda Frank, iPeter Ralph, iScott Knutson, iMandeep Khera, iSara Coslett, iAnn Frailey, i

  Home > Mainstream > Articles Popular: Books, Stories, Articles, Poetry     

Leslie P Garcia

· Become a Fan
· Contact me
· Books
· Articles
· Poetry
· News
· Stories
· Blog
· Messages
· 87 Titles
· 199 Reviews
· Save to My Library
· Share with Friends!
Member Since: Aug, 2001

Leslie P Garcia, click here to update your pages on AuthorsDen.

Featured Book
by William Walling

Very early in the First Century, three entire Roman legions, plus auxiliaries, cavalry, and camp followers were ambushed by a coalition of proto-Germanic tribal warriors ..  
BookAds by Silver
Gold and Platinum Members

Featured Book
Clothed in Virtue
by Coleen Maddy

We are all called to become saints in the kingdom of God, but we must be open to receiving His gracious gifts through faithful and humble hearts. This book, written from ..  
BookAds by Silver
Gold and Platinum Members

   Recent articles by
Leslie P Garcia

Life After Death by Lillie J. Roberts: A Review
Reaching the Unattainable
A Review: Firefly Run by Trish Milburn
Highlander's Bride by Deborah Gafford
Come Back to Me by Melissa Foster
Invitation to Ruin by Bronwen Evans
Midnight Sun by MJ Fredrick
Less than Demonic: an Opinion on Joe Paterno
Surrender by Jean Brashear
Unintended Consequences? The Casey Anthony Verdict
Do or Die: Atlanta and Standardized Testing
Why Teachers Whine: Performance?
           >> View all

The Insanity of Accommodation
By Leslie P Garcia   
Rated "PG" by the Author.
Last edited: Friday, January 05, 2007
Posted: Friday, January 05, 2007

Share    Print   Save    Become a Fan

Diversity and tolerance should be integral parts of the American fabric...but accommodation in the name of political gamemanship and correctness is shredding that fabric and abridging the rights of the many for the rights of the few.

Okay.  Enough.  Many AD regulars have probably read Regina Pounds’ very apt poem about political correctness, “Hogwash.”.  She hit a nail on the head that many of us avoid swinging at.  Still, if straws can break a camel’s back…


            A Muslim gentleman is making the rounds on news talk shows, explaining that his religious rights are being violated.  Isn’t this America? he asks.


            The problem?  He wants segregated cabs. Muslim cabs, he maintains, may not give rides to someone carrying alcohol. Muslims, it seems, also shouldn’t have to ride in a cab a dog might have been in; it’s an insult if some loving pet owner needed to ferry his or her animal to a vet or a kennel, and it keeps him from enjoying his guaranteed right to practice his religion.  And seeing eye dogs?  An infringement. 


            I unfortunately missed some of his conversation on the two shows I saw him on tonight, but maybe not unfortunately.  My blood pressure had already started to do me in.


            I almost never curse, but forgive me this one: where the hell does this stop? 


            The commentators rebutted his arguments with the obvious.  What if I, as a cab driver, am opposed to driving around men who mistreat women based on their religious tenets?  Rightly or wrongly, I have not heard acceptable reasons for the treatment of Muslim women.  Suppose a cab driver is an atheist, and would rather not drive a priest to a sickbed to administer last rites?  Suppose a cab driver is opposed on moral grounds to make-up?  I have a friend who will not wear it, because she believes the Bible bans it?  Should her fellow believers refuse rides to anyone wearing mascara or lipstick?


            On second thought, blood pressure or not, I wish I’d heard the whole diatribe of nonsense, because the conversation appeared to touch on other service areas besides cab drivers.  But the incredible idiocy of demanding segregated cabs kills me.  What, if someone who practices voodoo wants to sacrifice live animals in a cab?  Or at a school?


            Far-fetched?  Not at the rate this accommodation craziness is taking over. 


            Services cannot be abridged to meet the prejudices of the provider.  And religious beliefs to one are viewed as bigotry and prejudice by others of different faiths.  Should an airline pilot or a bus driver not carry passengers who carry alcohol?  Should the blind be unable to travel because their canine eyes offend someone?  Should a doctor whose belief says that homosexuality is a sin refuse to offer emergency treatment to a gay? 


I have no problem with the owners of private establishments denying services to someone who is drunk and may cause violence, or even refusing to allow a semi-nude person to eat in his her establishment.  But those are private businesses, and the owners are willing to accept financial loss to maintain order and safety.


 Businesses that close for religious holidays, regardless of what religious holiday, don’t bother me at all. Again, that is a public expression of private faith that may be an inconvenience to some, but that doesn’t punish particular groups or individuals who practice no religion or a different religion.  Businesses closing for religious observations don’t demand that I conform to the religious constraints of the store owners.  (Yes, I’m old enough to remember “blue laws.”  They were done away, at least in my various necks of the woods, many years ago—I believe on Constitutional issues.  Hmmm.  Wouldn’t not being able to carry one specific item in a cab be very similar to not being able to buy that item on a Sunday?) 


            Muslims involved in the cab flap are claiming their rights are being abridged, and that laws that don’t force others to observe their rules are prejudicial against Islam.


            I have experienced prejudice.  I was hated by some when I lived in rural Georgia—my parents were Yankees.  I married into the Hispanic culture.  My own father tried to kill my husband and me.  Hispanics have jeered me, “my” Anglo culture has called my children every name imaginable.  A restaurant in Bandera, Texas refused to pick up the tip my college-educated son left, because she didn’t want “money from them Mexicans.”  But you know what?  I’ve ignored it, or confronted it.  Never have I felt that others’ intolerance should be legislated to make my path easier.


            The same is true of religion.  I was brought up an Episcopalian until said father decided I was an atheist.  He became something of a celebrity, locking horns with the mostly Baptist preachers in our area.  But never did he expect them to accommodate his lack of belief—and I’m loath to praise him for anything.  In spite of his efforts to convert his children, most of us retain some loyalty to the faith of our childhood—showing perhaps, that one’s belief does not necessarily become another’s belief.


            Religious freedom means religious freedom for everyone, and it doesn’t mean that a person cannot express his or her faith because someone else might not practice the same religion.  Certainly it doesn’t mean that segregated cabs, airplanes, rooms in stores, and on and on should be dictated because specific groups have decided to campaign under clearly erroneous pretenses for “protection” of their rights.


            Segregated cabs…restrooms…schools…haven’t we been there?  Done that?  The only thing that the gentleman got right is that this is America…and because it is America, he can spew nonsense.  We can recognize the insanity and refuse to surrender to it.

Web Site: RioRendezvous

Reader Reviews for "The Insanity of Accommodation"

Want to review or comment on this article?
Click here to login!

Need a FREE Reader Membership?
Click here for your Membership!

Reviewed by Regina Pounds 1/8/2007
Leslie, a heart-felt opinion piece and thank you for mentioning my 'hogwash'...this reminds me of several pharmacy employees in my area. They refused to fill prescriptions for the Day-after anti pregnancy pill -- based on their own personal religious beliefs.

So we have it in action already. How does one stop this insane infliction of personal beliefs on the general public? It's beyond intolerance already -- not too mention the postering of those who demand and claim being offended...

Anyway, lest I get carried away: bravo for speaking out!

Reviewed by Jennifer Butler 1/6/2007
But, "diversity and tolerance"? That doesn't sound like true love to me. I think we should wear our favorite fabrics and choose styles that accomodate our individual lifestyles, without allowing others to decide for us just exactly who we are.

At Eagle's Edge: A Novel About Our Choices, Our Future And Our Enviro by Rosemary Patterson

Romance, Environmental novel about a Surfer Dude rescue of a sea lion from a massive Dilbit (Tar Sands Oil & Condensate) spill after huge tankers are allowed to travel the pristine..  
Featured BookAds by Silver
Gold and Platinum Members

The Women of Stormland by Lois Santalo

How can one person bring himself to enslave another? One way is to denigrate the enslaved person as less than human. Ashley Pennington, of mixed race, knows this trauma in her own ..  
Featured BookAds by Silver
Gold and Platinum Members

Authors alphabetically: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Featured Authors | New to AuthorsDen? | Add AuthorsDen to your Site
Share AD with your friends | Need Help? | About us

Problem with this page?   Report it to AuthorsDen
© AuthorsDen, Inc. All rights reserved.