Join Free! | Login    
   Popular! Books, Stories, Articles, Poetry
Where Authors and Readers come together!


Featured Authors:  Mark Seltman, iValerie, iChristina Neely, iScott Knutson, iWendy Laing, iM. Pritchard, iDavid Humphrey Sr, i

  Home > Health/Wellness > Articles Popular: Books, Stories, Articles, Poetry     

Jane St Clair

· + Follow Me
· Contact Me
· Books
· Articles
· Stories
· 55 Titles
· 30 Reviews
· Save to My Library
· Share with Friends!
Member Since: Jan, 2008

Jane St Clair, click here to update your pages on AuthorsDen.

Featured Book
Shadows of Eagles
by Stephen Lodge

Author's Special Edition..  
BookAds by Silver
Gold and Platinum Members

Now that you woke up from your coma, do you need us to kill you?
by Jane St Clair   
Rated "PG" by the Author.
Last edited: Sunday, November 14, 2010
Posted: Sunday, February 07, 2010

  Print   Save    Follow    Share 

Recent articles by
Jane St Clair

I Survived Hospice! Wear that tee shirt proudly!
Ten Myths About Legalizing Assisted Suicide
The St. Croix Cougar Belongs to the West
Living Wills, End-of-Life Medical Forms and the New York Times
Murder by Suicide: Internet Predator Attacks the Most Vulnerable Among Us
Grandma's Suicide Kit Backfires
Sonoran Desert Spring, April Spring, Tucson, Arizona
           >> View all

No one is a "vegetable" - new research shows people in comas and semi-conscious states are more conscious than we used to think

                      by Jane St Clair

Author of Walk Me to Midnight


Rom Houben was a handsome athletic student who landed up paralyzed after a terrible accident. Unable to communicate, he lay in the back wards of nursing homes for 23 long years. Then one of his doctors got creative and used technology to scan his brain. To everyone’s astonishment except his mother’s, Rom had been fully conscious and aware all that time.

The case is changing what we know about patients in a vegetative state also known as the “brain-dead.”  Most recently, a team of researchers in Britain and Belgium studied 54 patients identified as “vegetative” and found that one in ten was conscious to a degree no one thought possible. When the doctors asked them questions such as, “Do you have a brother?” — the “yes” and “no” parts of their brains lit up in a similar way that they do in normal people. When some of them thought about tennis, they could “play tennis” in their minds. This study appears in the latest edition of the New England Journal of Medicine.

Another study done last year at Liege’s Coma Science Group found that 41% of patients diagnosed as being in vegetative states were actually minimally conscious.

You’d think that results like this would excite medical people and push research into a new and different direction, maybe to answer questions like: How can we better communicate with people who are minimally conscious? Is there a way to enable them to use robots and computers to talk to us? How can they let us know if they are comfortable? What do they need right now? Is there a way to help them better participate in society?  In the “Star Wars” movies, all the doctors were robots.

Just as the space program opened up amazing breakthroughs in computer development and miniaturization, so could such research among minimally conscious people help us develop new ways of teaching, learning, and communicating. Perhaps we could even find the breakthroughs we need to help autistic children, now one in every 100 babies born in the United States.

Yet when the New York Times reported on the New England Journal of Medicine research on its front page February 4, 2009, what was their concern? Not breakthroughs in science. Not how to better communicate with minimally conscious people –no, sir — none of the above.  Their big concern was medical ethics. If 10% to 41% of  brain-dead people are minimally conscious, is it still okay to remove their feeding tubes? Knowing that they are minimally conscious makes it harder for families to decide “end of life” issues. Talk about robot-doctors!

In the Times article,  Dr. Joseph Fins, chief of the medical ethics division at Weill Cornell Medical College in New York, expressed this worry — “If you ask the patient whether he or she wants to live or die, and the answer is to die,  would you be convinced the answer was sufficient?” Is that really the first question we should ask them when they wake up? Now that you’re awake, do you want us to kill you?

Dr. Alan Ropper, a neurologist at Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston, said in an editorial accompanying the research in the New England Journal, “Physicians and society are not ready for ‘I have brain activity. Therefore I am.’” Why not?

So the question is not how can we better communicate and help these people, but whether they should live or die. Under some of the provisions in new legislation now before Congress,  health care providers paid with government money could withhold food and water from people in such states of consciousness, even though that is probably a violation of the Americans with Disabilities Act. And, as Rom Houben clearly teaches us, mistakes happen.


Bookmark and Share



Carey, Benedict. “Trace of Thought Is Found in ‘Vegetative’ Patient,” The New York Times, page one, February 4, 2010.

Tutton, Mark. “Trapped Coma Man: How was he misdiagnosed?” CNN, November 24, 2009,






Web Site: The Compassionate Choice

Want to review or comment on this article?
Click here to login!

Need a FREE Reader Membership?
Click here for your Membership!

Popular Health/Wellness Articles
  1. 2014 Top Recommended Health Products
  2. little known ways to increase your energy
  3. Welcome to my West Virginia
  4. ORDEAL !
  5. Healing from Grief
  6. Is It Stress or Burnout? 7 Signs You Shou
  7. Cold and Flu Season or is it?
  8. improving your eyes with these tricks pick
  9. DUH ?
  10. Is Life Just an Impulse ?

The Food Contrarian by Tuchy (Carl) Palmieri

”The Food Contrarian” Quotes for people recovering from or dealing with eating issues. The 12 step movements are filled with proverbs, sayings and slogans that combine to provi..  
BookAds by Silver, Gold and Platinum Members

Warrior Patient: How to Beat Deadly Diseases With Laughter, Good Docto by Temple Williams

Warrior Patient will change how you approach the miracles of modern medicine. Read the stunning, and the surprisingly funny story of someone who recovers completely from a relentle..  
BookAds by Silver, Gold and Platinum Members

Authors alphabetically: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Featured Authors | New to AuthorsDen? | Add AuthorsDen to your Site
Share AD with your friends | Need Help? | About us

Problem with this page?   Report it to AuthorsDen
© AuthorsDen, Inc. All rights reserved.