Join (Free!) | Login  

     Popular! Books, Stories, Articles, Poetry
   Services MarketPlace (Free to post!)
Where Authors and Readers come together!


Featured Authors:  J.J. Snow, iWilliam Wright, iElisabeth Barstowe, ijude forese, iG M (Jerry) Roberts, iLonnie Hicks, iVaughn Aiken, i

  Home > Political Science > Articles Popular: Books, Stories, Articles, Poetry     

Jane St Clair

· Become a Fan
· Contact me
· Books
· Articles
· Stories
· 55 Titles
· 30 Reviews
· Save to My Library
· Share with Friends!
Member Since: Jan, 2008

Jane St Clair, click here to update your pages on AuthorsDen.

Featured Book
The War on Christians
by Will Clark

Is there really a war on Christians as some suggest? Absolutely - positively, and the war is more widespread and in-depth than many doubters might believe. There are real..  
BookAds by Silver
Gold and Platinum Members

Featured Book
101 Obama Blogs
by Will Clark

Now available in Kindle - and only $.99. This is a book of 101 blogs I posted on Authorsden during the past three years regarding Barack Hussein Obama and his administrat..  
BookAds by Silver
Gold and Platinum Members

   Recent articles by
Jane St Clair

I Survived Hospice! Wear that tee shirt proudly!
Ten Myths About Legalizing Assisted Suicide
The St. Croix Cougar Belongs to the West
Living Wills, End-of-Life Medical Forms and the New York Times
Murder by Suicide: Internet Predator Attacks the Most Vulnerable Among Us
Grandma's Suicide Kit Backfires
Sonoran Desert Spring, April Spring, Tucson, Arizona
Civil War Re-Enactment at Picacho Peak: The Gettysburg of the West
Tragedy in Our Tucson Neighborhood: Gabrielle Giffords Shot
To Molly with Love on National Suicide Survivors' Day
Cowboys Gather for Symposium In Sonoita, Arizona
The New Rx Cure: Assisted Suicide as Medical Treatment
           >> View all

Assisted Suicide and Your End-of-Life Chats with Your Doctor
By Jane St Clair   
Rated "PG" by the Author.
Last edited: Sunday, November 14, 2010
Posted: Tuesday, July 28, 2009

Share    Print   Save    Become a Fan

End of life chats with doctors are about helping you choose the cheapest health care possible to save the system money.

Assisted Suicide and Your End-of-Life Chats with Your Doctor


Jane St Clair



Fifteen years ago, Colorado’s governor Richard Lamm got himself in trouble by saying elderly people have “a duty to die and get out of the way.”

Lamm knew how much end-of-life care costs. About one-third of Medicare’s budget goes for costs incurred in the last one year of life, and 40% of that goes for expenses in the last one month of life.  It is so much cheaper if old people just do their duty and get out of the way rather than use hospitals, expensive tests and surgeries, and medications.

Congress knows this too, which is why they include Section 1233 in the proposed health care reform bill.

Under Section 1233, doctors get paid to sit down with all patients over 65 years old to talk about end-of-life issues.  The idea is to encourage people to sign living wills and enter hospices rather than getting expensive treatments. Since hospice provides only pain relief and palliative care, everyone else saves money. Under the new rules, you enter hospice when you have only 18 months to live, compared to today’s six months-- so this way you speed things along even faster for us.  In states where physician-assisted suicide is legal, end-of-life talks would no doubt include assisted suicide, the cheapest option of all.

The lawmakers  pushing cheap “end-of-life” healthcare call it the “complete lives system.” The idea is that old people have already led “complete lives,” so it’s time for them to do their duty, as Lamm put it.

The lawmakers behind these proposals are compassionate. They don’t like that dying people suffer, and they don’t like that a 90-year-old with cancer takes a government Handy Van to chemotherapy, while a baby in Africa dies because he can’t get clean water.  In fact, none of us like that, and we all agree something has to be done.

The problem is putting our compassionate ideas into practice. Even very smart compassionate people are not smart enough to make every decision for everyone else.  And what happens in practice is that most people want every treatment possible at the end of their lives.  Who gets to decide which people get which treatments?

Jane Strum spoke up at a presidential press conference in July 2009. Five years ago, her mother got a pacemaker at age 99 years, and is still alive today. Under the new government plan, Strum asked, would there just be cut-offs at certain ages, or would doctors be able to consider factors likes a “certain spirit? A certain joy of living?” Her mother’s doctors considered those things.

President Obama answered Jane Strum like this.

 “We can let doctors know, and we can let your mom know,” he said, “that maybe this is not going to help. Maybe you’re better off not having the surgery, but taking the painkiller.”

In this particular case, however, if you believe she would be better off not having the surgery but taking the painkiller, you believe she would be better off dead.

Let’s look at the particular cases of Randy Stroup and Barbara Wagner, who have cancer. They are sort-of old people: Stroup is 53 years old and Wagner is 64. They both got letters from the state of Oregon, which pays their medical expenses. The letters said that Oregon won’t pay their cancer treatments because each has only a slim chance of living more than five years.  However, the good news is that Oregon will pay for a painless, doctor-assisted suicide, defining it as “comfort care,” and including it as just another choice for them, like taking painkillers.  They could choose to be humanely put to sleep, the way you’d do for a beloved pet.

What this means is that some of the most caring people among us are willing to reduce each of us to a bunch of numbers, statistics, and risk factors because they think this will make things better for humanity as a whole.  It is medicine by accountancy. Accountancy has no philosophy or art in it. It lacks what Wordsworth called “the sweet sad music of humanity."

The New York Times reports that six Senators are sitting around a table making these decisions. There are no doctors, nurses, nursing home attendants, psychologists, medical ethicists, theologians, priests, rabbis, artists, shamans, and wise elders in these discussions. Congress alone decides who must do the noble thing and die for our country, the same way they make laws deciding who gets the criminal death penalty and who must go to war.

One of the first things they decided was to exempt themselves from healthcare reforms like Section 1322 and vote to keep their own healthcare plan just the way it is, thus avoiding end-of-life chats, issues of “complete lives,” duties to die, and assisted suicide.

Assisted suicide is like the line from the movie, “Young Frankenstein,” when Igor whispers, “Wait, Master, it might be dangerous. You go first.”

Since Congress is proposing this, and since the way is very dangerous, they should go first.




Web Site: The Compassionate Choice

Reader Reviews for "Assisted Suicide and Your End-of-Life Chats with Your Doctor"

Want to review or comment on this article?
Click here to login!

Need a FREE Reader Membership?
Click here for your Membership!

Reviewed by Patricia Hilliard 11/22/2010
This is a very informative article. It made me question the Assisted Suicide arguments that I had begun to accept. I began to realize that the "End of Life Chats" could lead to thinking that anyone over 65 is unnecessary and could be denied any kind of medical treatment. Is this how they are going to solve the economic crisis? I think other methods could be used. Why do we accept the idea that rich people are allowed to get richer and richer while poor people are left to starve and die? Dividing the wealth more equally would mean that everyone could live to a happy old age. Thank you for writing this article.
Reviewed by John Martin 7/28/2009
If these Nazis occupying our government need help with their suicide, I'll be glad to assist.

Kipp The Kid by Paul Day

All Kipp wants to do is explore the old mines. But when girl next door Jane enters the picture, his life becomes more complex, more frustrating, but far more interesting...  
Featured BookAds by Silver
Gold and Platinum Members

Free Download - Putin's Russia by Sam Vaknin

Russia's economy and politics under Vladimir Putin. ..  
Featured BookAds by Silver
Gold and Platinum Members

Authors alphabetically: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Featured Authors | New to AuthorsDen? | Add AuthorsDen to your Site
Share AD with your friends | Need Help? | About us

Problem with this page?   Report it to AuthorsDen
AuthorsDen, Inc. All rights reserved.