Join Free! | Login 

   Popular! Books, Stories, Articles, Poetry
Where Authors and Readers come together!

Signed Bookstore | Authors | eBooks | Books | Stories | Articles | Poetry | Blogs | News | Events | Reviews | Videos | Success | Gold Members | Testimonials

Featured Authors: Francis Eaden, iMyra Darwish, iAllen Smith, iSara Coslett, iDenise Richardson, iJohn MacEachern, iPhyllis Jean Green, i
  Home > Political Science > Stories
Popular: Books, Stories, Articles, Poetry     

Mel Hathorn

  + Follow Me   

· 72 titles
· 85 Reviews
· Share with Friends!
· Save to My Library
Member Since: Apr, 2002

   Contact Author
   Read Reviews

· The Prisoner's Dilemma

· Celts and Kings

· The Castlereagh Connection

Short Stories
· Thanksgiving Day Dinner at Oliver Wight Tavern in Old Sturbridge Village

· Spanking Plato: Prologue - Chapter 3

· Sticking it to the Man

· Women in White: Parts 1-6

· Men In Black

· The Corporation Who Mistook Itself for a Person

· The Gymnast

· No Broccoli Tonight!!!

· The Prisoner's Dilemma (Authors note)

· The Prisoner 's Dilemma Prologue

· Stages in the development of Social Change

· But Who's Going To Clean The Toilets?

· George Will's Unanswered Questions

· The People's Fund

· Letter to World Leaders

· An Open Letter to Connecticut Transit

· Constitutional Amendment to end Corporate Personhood

· Is Reaganomics Dead?

· A Reasonable Teaching Philosophy?

· No Taxation Without Representation

· Georgie Porgie

· The Battle Hymn of the Republic Updated" contributed

· Lament for Lost Liberties

         More poetry...
· A New Business!

· Spanking Plato

· Nobel Prize Nomination

· The First Crack in the Wall

· Are the predictions I made in The Prisoner’s Dilemma happening?

· Get The Prisoner's Dilemma free!

· Dust Cover Copy for The Prisoner's Dilemma

Mel Hathorn, click here to update your web pages on AuthorsDen.

Books by Mel Hathorn
A Study and Discussion Guide to The Prisoner's Dilemma
By Mel Hathorn
Posted: Tuesday, April 20, 2010
Last edited: Tuesday, April 20, 2010
This short story is rated "G" by the Author.
Share    Print   Save   Become a Fan
Recent stories by Mel Hathorn
· Spanking Plato: Prologue - Chapter 3
· Thanksgiving Day Dinner at Oliver Wight Tavern in Old Sturbridge Village
· Sticking it to the Man
· Hartford PGA Tour: Going to the Dogs?
· Women in White: Parts 1-6
· The Corporation Who Mistook Itself for a Person
· Men In Black
           >> View all 27
The following discussion guide to my new novel, The Prisoner's Dilemma, is available free if you request it by emailing me. Below is the table of contents and a list of some of the discussion questions.





Mighty Meadows

Parents and Families

Other Main Characters

Justices of the Supreme Court


David Killiam
Susan Jones
Taney Smith
John Michaels
Marshall Mason
Leonard Limpson
Donald Wilson
Alan Gates



Justice vs. mercy
The banality of evil


The Heroes Journey (Quest)
The Prisoner’s Dilemma and the Tragedy of the Commons


Lilly Pond
Stagecoach robber
Mark Twain
Jungian archetypes (There are many more archetypes than those listed here)


Prologue through Chapter 3 Summary and Analysis:

Chapters 4 – 7 Summary and Analysis:

Chapters 8 – 12 Summary and Analysis:

Chapter 13 Summary and Analysis:

Chapters 14 – 17 Summary and Analysis:

Chapters 18 – 24 Summary and Analysis:

Chapter 25 Summary and Analysis:

Chapters 26 – 27Summary and Analysis:

Chapters 28 – 32 Summary and Analysis:

Chapters 18 – 24 Summary and Analysis:

Chapters 41 – 44 Summary and Analysis:

Chapters 45 – 51Summary and Analysis:

Epilogue Summary and Analysis:




DISCUSSION QUESTIONS for middle and high school students

1. Is privacy protected by the Constitution? Why or why not?

2. How does an originalist Justice on the Supreme Court interpret the Constitution?

3. Susan tells her 8th grade class, “Do you know that there is a group of nine people in Washington that can tell you what to do? They can support or deny laws that tell you what you can and cannot read. This group can tell you when the police can arrest you or have to let you go.

These people can take away your most basic civil rights in the name of national security. They can make law or change law as well as destroy laws or enforce them. Appointed for life, they answer to no one. These are probably the most powerful people in the country if not the world. More powerful then the President or Congress, they are appointed for life and unless they die, resign, or are impeached cannot be removed from office."

How do you feel about all the power the Supreme Court has? What checks and balances are there for the Supreme Court? Should the Court have all this power?

4. In George Orwell’s book, Animal Farm, there is a set of rules. One is: All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others. The Declaration of Independence says all men are created equal Are all men created equal? What does that mean? Does it mean that all are “born equal?” The Declaration does not use the term, “Born Equal.” It uses the term “Created Equal.” Is there a difference between the two terms? What are the implications of this distinction?

5. If as some people say, a corporation is a person, does that mean that the Creator “Created” a corporation to be equal to a person? Or did man create the corporation? Does corporate personhood violate the spirit if not the intent of the Declaration? Is it sacrilegious to call a corporation a person? Does that title usurp the powers of the Creator?

DISCUSSION QUESTIONS for College Students and Adults

1. What is the meaning of the statement in The Declaration of Independence that reads, “All men are created equal?” Does this apply to corporations? To animals?

2. What is the Prisoner’s Dilemma? How does it relate to the story?

3. How can one escape the prisoner’s dilemma? What does it mean when Phillip J. Eby says in the Epigraph “that the only way out of the Prisoner's Dilemma is for somebody to not defect, to not sell out their dream because they're afraid of being sold out first.…Somebody has to go first, and be willing to accept the consequences.” Is it possible or even desirable in today’s world to follow that path? What are the consequences for one who does take that road?

4. The theme of justice vs. mercy is implied throughout the story. Which dominates in today’s legal system? Should it be reversed? How could it be reversed?

5. How does the Gilded Age impact us today? What are the long-term implications for today and going forward into the future?

6. Madison argued that the original intent of the framers must be based on the ratification debates rather than the debates at the Constitutional Convention. What do you think?

7. How does an originalist justify a literal interpretation of the Constitution if there are no Framers around to ask?

8. In Chapter 45, Susan and Killiam are interviewed on the Oprah Winfrey Show. Susan says the following: When we first began this lawsuit a couple of years ago, we wanted nothing more than to punish those person’s responsible for their negligence. Over time we realized that punishment was not the answer. Rather, it became more important to send a loud and clear message that those putting the public at risk will be held accountable.

Let me put it another way. It’s not about punishing Mighty Meadows. It’s not even about punishing Taney Smith; it’s about accountability. We wanted to make it clear to all those who seek to profit at the expense of the public welfare that they will be held accountable and responsible for their actions. It was justice we were seeking, not money. We knew it was time we Americans stood up for ourselves. Therefore, after much research and hard work by our Attorney, David Killiam, and others we decided to go a different route. We knew it would be difficult. We didn’t know how difficult it would be.

What are the personal changes that the parents and Susan have gone through? Have they replaced anger and revenge with the desire for justice and accountability? Is it possible that the parents could move to acceptance? Even forgiveness?

9. In Chapter 30, Smith has decided to roll on his fellow cohorts. This chapter also shows Smith descending into irrationality by running across the parking lot. What does this act show us about Smith? Is this a final downfall and if so, is it a result of a character flaw? Or could this have been avoided had he acted differently at some earlier point in his life? If Smith has a fatal flaw, what is it? How free was Smith to avoid this end



Want to review or comment on this short story?
Click here to login!

Need a FREE Membership?
Click here to Join!

Popular Political Science Stories
1. Dodge Coronet
2. The day of the Holocaust
3. Two People Talking - Not a Bad Idea
4. Arab Spring - Success or Failure?
5. La vérité nue que tous les êtres devraient
6. Israeli “Students accuse US of 'ulterior m
7. Le pauvre et le millionnaire
8. Reality Faced
9. Politic-king

Authors alphabetically: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Featured Authors | New to AuthorsDen? | Add AuthorsDen to your Site
Share AD with your friends | Need Help? | About us

Problem with this page?   Report it to AuthorsDen
© AuthorsDen, Inc. All rights reserved.