A short article referring to bilingual education in today's society.
I was reading a very small article under the "Letters" section in one of the local newspapers. I will share parts of it with all of you. "While I agree that schools should start teaching foreign language before high school, I do not agree that we should be forced to learn English and Spanish." I would think learning English a top priority. This is the language spoken in this country. Everyone comes from different backgrounds and sometimes speak a foreign language in the home. There is absolutely nothing wrong with this. However, when you venture to step outside the home English is the given language to communicate. This is also a vital part of the puzzle to assimilate into the culture. There is on the other hand a problem with the educational structure. I keep hearing about bilingual education, yet the only foreign language offered is Spanish. Why is that? What happened to the hundreds of other languages spoken around the world. Why is it only Spanish that is shoved down out throats? "The idea that Mr. Parks wants to push undermines the foundation on which this country was founded. You come to America as an immigrant and you assimilate. That means you learn the language of the country and you become a productive person and citizen." I could not have said it better myself. In chapter five of my book, pages 95 - 96, I address a portion of this issue from my own perspective. "Yes, they (my grandparents) had a much larger hurdle to overcome and that was to learn how to speak, read and write in English instead of their native tongue. They were never asked to learn to speak Spanish, which seems to be the main agenda of today's society. They took it upon themsleves to learn English because that was, is and hopefully will always be the main language spoken here in America. They kept all of the knowledge of their cultural traditions that they brought with them when they came here, around the turn of the twentiety century. That was important for them not to lose their basic heritage, but they also realized that if their children were to have any chance of a future they would have to learn the language and customs here. As I was growing up I was in a fortunate position to grow up in a bilingual home and I did it with pride. I was, as I am now, very proud of my family, my heritage and I am also very proud to ba an American as well. I believe that I was able to live with the very best of both worlds and then to be able to incorporate it all to where it has brought me to today. The illegal immigrants that are crossing our borders to sneak their way into our country really, in my opinion are wrong. I do understand their plight, but it is wrong the way they are doing it. If they want to come into our country then they should seek all of the legal channels that are available to them. Do it legally, even if it may take a little longer than they would like. To enter this country illegally is really an insult to my family and to many other families that did come here legally. Get my point? I really do understand what most of them are trying to do and why they have such an uncontrollable urge to leave their home to come here. I think sometimes that if I were in their shoes I would probably want to do the same thing. I mean leave the despiar and hopelessness of my home land and try to make a life for myself and my family in another country. The difference is that I would try to search for all of the legal channels and enter the country in the right way. Hopefully in time to become a productive citizen, if that is what my individual goals were to be."
Thank you for taking the time to read what I have written.
It would sure make it easier for the children who come with them. Our elementary school now has at least twenty five Mexican children whom are very sweet children and add a bit of spice to the classroom and diversity which is healthy for children to learn other cultures and ways of life, but the children who are suffering are the Mexican children whom are having to learn from teachers who do not speak Spanish, and are teaching them to read with American phonics...it makes it very difficult for them when their parents do not speak english at home, and also have subscribed to spanish television channels, school is the only place that these children are being exposed to the english language, yet are expected to be proficient in english...I agree they should learn the language if no other reason to help their own children. Great write.
Blessings,
Joyce Bowling
Reviewed by Flying Fox Ted L Glines (Reader)
Reviewed on January 24, 2007
Darned good article, Karen, and well written!
There is a further problem which must, somehow be addressed. The Mexican people coming here, both illegal and legal, come to live in inner-city neighborhoods (barrios) where Mexican is the predominant language in a sequestered subcultural environment where they are protected against being "changed" into "Anglos." This is sometimes a rough environment where gangs like "La Raza" rule, drugs are prevalent, and so is prostitution. These people come here to earn money, and the illegals are hired secretly by our own business capitalists in many workplaces. The illegals, because they are illegal, largely do not expose themselves to our school system, and their own familias in the neighborhoods are not equipped to tutor them in English. The same is true of those illegals who live in the large camps which house the migrant farm workers. Finally, since they are illegal, they know that they are forever fugitives, and they feel hunted by us, and they therefore view us as their enemy. End result is that they are entrapped in a situation where the least of their problems is "learning English." Somehow, before this gap may be bridged, the fact of their illegality must be addressed and solved. I would guess, for the most part, that the Mexicans who are here legally are willing and anxious to learn English so they may progress to better jobs and move out of the camps and ghettos.
You are absolutely right -- they should find legal means to come here. But there is the very corrupt Mexican system, and there is also a corrupt American business system -- both of them encouraging the illegal entries. We need to solve that. Now.
Karen, again I agree with you about the many frustrations that this country is going through, what I don't agree on is that Spanish is being shoved down the throats of any U.S. citizen. There are choices when in high school and I recall in the late sixties and early seventies when I was in school there was also a choice of the French language though I was fluent in English and I am a U.S. citizen born and raised here. The facts are correct as you state that many illegal immigrants are here illegally and they should follow the correct way of entering and becoming U.S. citizens but there are also a great many who are already citizens and don't debate the necesity to learn and become knowledgeable in the English language and the ways of the soceity of the U.S. There are ways to make or state your point without being against the people who are striving to become a part of this great country.
I also feel that some take the problem and make it seem that all the illegal immigration is of a crime oriented people and that placing them within a need to control them through birth control will solve the issue. I wonder if when the need to be bi-lingual to become a more successful or to attain the employment that enriches one and his family what will be the issue and the answer that many will have.
Fortunately for me I was born here in the U.S. not like the unfortunate childhood of my lovely wife who was a Mexican born citizen and who willingly gave that citizenship away to become a U.S. citizen and without the background of education learned the English language and is a very successful and productive citizen of the United States of America.
Please do not take any of my comments personally for I do agree with your article overall and myself and my wife agree if you come here then learn English and be here....LEGALLY...
I agree with this write. My family on my fathers side came here as early as the late 1500's as merchants. My grandfather on my mothers side came from Sicily. All of them still speak fluent Italian in Watertown New York. Yet they embraced the new land, and accepted the English language as their new language.
You bring up some very good points here, I am not fluent in spanish myself, when foreign languages were offered in highschool I choose sign language...
God Bless
Michelle R Kidwell
Exploring the impact of literary icon Flannery O'Connor's noted legacy on the cultural realities of modern-day America, the world, and a certain author.
Exploring the impact of literary icon Flannery O'Connor's noted legacy on the cultural realities of modern-day America, the world, and a certain author.
Blessings,
Joyce Bowling
There is a further problem which must, somehow be addressed. The Mexican people coming here, both illegal and legal, come to live in inner-city neighborhoods (barrios) where Mexican is the predominant language in a sequestered subcultural environment where they are protected against being "changed" into "Anglos." This is sometimes a rough environment where gangs like "La Raza" rule, drugs are prevalent, and so is prostitution. These people come here to earn money, and the illegals are hired secretly by our own business capitalists in many workplaces. The illegals, because they are illegal, largely do not expose themselves to our school system, and their own familias in the neighborhoods are not equipped to tutor them in English. The same is true of those illegals who live in the large camps which house the migrant farm workers. Finally, since they are illegal, they know that they are forever fugitives, and they feel hunted by us, and they therefore view us as their enemy. End result is that they are entrapped in a situation where the least of their problems is "learning English." Somehow, before this gap may be bridged, the fact of their illegality must be addressed and solved. I would guess, for the most part, that the Mexicans who are here legally are willing and anxious to learn English so they may progress to better jobs and move out of the camps and ghettos.
You are absolutely right -- they should find legal means to come here. But there is the very corrupt Mexican system, and there is also a corrupt American business system -- both of them encouraging the illegal entries. We need to solve that. Now.
Ted
I also feel that some take the problem and make it seem that all the illegal immigration is of a crime oriented people and that placing them within a need to control them through birth control will solve the issue. I wonder if when the need to be bi-lingual to become a more successful or to attain the employment that enriches one and his family what will be the issue and the answer that many will have.
Fortunately for me I was born here in the U.S. not like the unfortunate childhood of my lovely wife who was a Mexican born citizen and who willingly gave that citizenship away to become a U.S. citizen and without the background of education learned the English language and is a very successful and productive citizen of the United States of America.
Please do not take any of my comments personally for I do agree with your article overall and myself and my wife agree if you come here then learn English and be here....LEGALLY...
Respectfully ...Art Sun Hernandez...
Irrespective You Are On Of Few Who Write About This On Going Insanity
Which Only Spells Them Keep Coming -"CHEAP LABOR"...
They Will Never Learn English But Know How Steal& Spend $1.00 Bill In Espanol Englese Sleazy...
TRASK
God Bless
Michelle R Kidwell