In a small-town borough of Chester County, Pennsylvania, Becca Wallace’s faith is tested as she wonders what kind of cruel joke God is playing on her family. A mysterious fire forces them out of their home, and their delinquent son has left without a trace. Also, something odd is holding up the adoption of their beloved granddaughter, Tally, who is their whole world.

Becca and her husband make the best of their lives despite the setbacks, and she would do anything to keep them all together. One day the child goes missing. Frantically, Becca puts her life at stake to find the little girl. While searching for Tally, a friend's disturbing betrayal shakes Becca’s resolve, but the issue pales to what she unexpectedly encounters next—something that defies even her own imagination.

Who burned down the house? Is there someone from Becca’s past causing trouble for the family? Will Tally be found safe or is it too late?