AuthorsDen.com   Join | Login    
Where Authors and Readers come together!

SIGNED BOOKS    AUTHORS    BOOKS    SAMPLE CHAPTERS    AUDIOBOOKS    eBOOKS    STORIES    ARTICLES    POETRY    BLOGS    NEWS    VIDEOS    SUCCESS    TESTIMONIALS

Featured Authors:  Margaret Mullings, iDietmar Rothe, iBryon Smith, iFERIAL Haque, iAntoinette Kopperfield, iKarin Adams, iDebra Kraft, iBethany Peterson, iJudith Bailey, i RickthePoetWarrior, i

  Home > Literary Criticism > Articles Popular: Books, Stories, Articles, Poetry      Authors: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z     

T. Wignesan

 Follow Me  

· Contact Me
· Books
· Articles
· Poetry
· News
· Events
· Stories
· 698 Titles
· 727 Reviews
· Save to My Library
· Share with Friends!
·
Member Since: May, 2018

T. Wignesan, click here to update your pages on AuthorsDen.


The Anatomy of the Kural, the Classical Tamil distique in the Vennba metre
by T. Wignesan   
Rated "G" by the Author.
     
Recent articles by
T. Wignesan

• Eric Mottram's letter and recommendation dated Mar. 3, 1958 to T. Wignesan
• 3rd Letter from Bill GRIFFITHS on the Eric MOTTRAM Archive at King's Co
• 2nd Letter from Bill GRIFFITHS on the Eric MOTTRAM Archive at King's Co
• Correspondence with Bill GRIFFITHS on the Eric MOTTRAM Archive at King's Co
• Eric MOTTRAM's letter dated 22Feb1990 addressed to T. Wignesan in Paris
           >> View all

How a KURAL (distique/couplet) in Classical Tamil literature, dating from some 1500 years, was composed, the Master craftsman having been Thiru-Valluvar, reputedly of the priesthood caste officiating for the lowest social outcastes: the Untouchables.

The Anatomy of a Kural: Maxim 245 of the Thirukkural by Thiruvalluvar
The Anatomy of a Kural: Maxim Number 245 (taken at random) of the Thirukkural, the Tamil Classic on Ethics by Thiruvalluvar

allal arulaalvaarkku illai valivalangum

mallalmaa naalam kari (K245)

“The teeming earth's vast realm, round which the wild winds blow,
Is witness, men of 'grace' no woeful want shall know.” (Tr. G.W.Pope)

“This great rich earth over which the wind blows, is a witness that sorrow never comes upon the kind-hearted.” (Tr. W.H.Drew and John Lazarus)

“Misfortune the good-natured spares, the wind-tossed
Great cornucopian world bears ever testimony.” (Tr. T. Wignesan)

allal=privation or affliction

arul=kindliness, benevolence

aalvaar(kku)=to those who manage or exercise; (ukku)=here denotes the dative case ending

illai=negation (no/not)

vali=wind

valangkum=passing round

mallal=abundance

ma=great

naalam=the pendant globe of earth

kari=witness



Now the task here for the poet is to put these senses of the words together in an arrangement of seven metrical feet to comply with the classical Tamil prosodic rules while incorporating certain rhetorical features, such as, initial rhyme (ethukai), alliteration (monai), exceptionally end-rhyme (iyaippu), typical to a particular metre called "venba".

Example of "ethukai": allal/mallal. The rules require that the rhyme must fall on the second syllable, here: "ll" or as pronounced “il”.

Example of "monai": line one = a/a/aa/i/ (according to the rules "a" and "i" (or as pronounced “e”) for the sake of alliteration are phonetic equivalents.

Feet: There are seven metrical feet in each "kural" or couplet or distique, four in the first line and three in the second, though now and then this pattern may be reversed.

The feet are represented by both the short syllable: "-" and the long: "_". This distique (given the lack of adequate diacritical signs on my computer) could be transcribed as follows:

-- -- -_ _ _ - - --_ ----_

--_ _ _ -- --*

* lines above are short, lines below long.

In order to respect the brevity of these pithy sayings, the author has also to constrict the grammatical structure of the sentence (often a complex sentence with a main and a subordinate clause) by the adroit use of ellipses through omitting case endings or post-positional morphemes, etc., and by the use of substantives to take the place of verbs and by juggling the words in groups through meaningful juxtapositions.

To illustrate this device, see how he uses the negative particle "illai" placed further away from the noun "allal" which it qualifies; or see how he separates the epithet: "valivalangkum" from the "noun" it qualifies in the next line while interposing yet another two epithets in between. The last word, the seventh is almost always only made up of two short syllables.

Thiruvalluvar has had to cope with all these poetical and prosodic devices and literary embellishments, such as, the use of imagery, metaphor or simile, and even ambiguity, all through 1330 couplets, arranged according to thematic chapters of ten distiques apiece. This exercise in itself is a veritable achievement, not to mention the overall philosophic treatment of his thesis which is the admonishment of a way of life for a people in all the aspects of the domestic, amorous, social and political spheres of their existence.

Little wonder then why the Thirukkural has enjoyed the highest place of praise and pride in the hearts of an entire Tamil population which can boast of having engendered a totally unrelated/isolated family of languages in South India (including Brahui in present-day Pakistan) with a continuous corpus of literary masterpieces lasting over at least two-thousand three hundred years.

© T. Wignesan - Paris, 2017

Copyright © T Wignesan | Year Posted 2017

    


Want to review or comment on this article?


Need a FREE Reader Membership?
Reviewed by T. Wignesan
Reviewed on October 7, 2021
Hi, Ron! Just noted that we are still friends after the manner in which you excluded me from the Den. Never mind! A sock or two under the chin or under the belt can sometimes jolt one's senses and keep concussion at bay. Let me try this remedy out and see if it works:

So you now think I didn't use unsavoury methods like "pathetic pithyless shrill" techniques (cf. your poem reaching out to members of the DEN) to judge Thiru-Valluvar's masterpiece???

I always did think you were the Sagittarius kind to roam the world in search of TRUTH.

Did you know Romans and Greeks traded with Tamil kingdoms and exchanged ambassadors fomenting cultural ties "long" before Alexander conquered the Indian North West Frontier region??? Romans actually greatly appreciated Tamil girls as prostitutes in Rome. Read the "Peripulus of the Erytherean Sea" (my spelling might be slightly askew).

Reviewed by Ronald Hull
Reviewed on October 6, 2021
You have an amazing knowledge of literature and ways of analyzing it that are nearly incomparable to anything that I have read. Keep up the good work!

Ron

Popular Literary Criticism Articles
  1.  The Art of Romare Bearden and History
  2.  As Do You Really Read News...
  3.  10 Books Keeping One Writer’s Company
  4.  Lee's and Morrison's New Works May Inf
  5.  Edgar Allen Poe: His Rhythm with Roman
  6.  A Teachers View on Educating a Child
  7.  In Search of the Muse-Goddess
  8.  WEYTIN WE GAIN
  9.  The stigma of Self Publication
  10.  Innocence Lost in James Joyce’s “Araby
  11.  Reconciling Flannery O’Connor’s Litera
  12.  Existential Pythiatism
  13.  Is Donald Trump the Modern King Lear?
  14.  Techniques for De-Branding the Authori
  15.  What Ever Happened to Free Speech? A R
  16.  Savannah Author Flannery O'Connor: A W
  17.  The Comedy of Survival - Book Review
  18.  The Critic
  19.  UNDEFINABLE CRAP
  20.  Analysis of Jonathan Edward’s Sermon “
  21.  Author Gore Vidal and the Sexual Signs
  22.  Eva's Man
  23.  Text and Meaning in Albert Camus' The
  24.  A Book Review is a Mirror in Another W
  25.  3 H - P 9

Free Book Review Program
Select a book to read and review today!

O. Henry: Obscenely and Outrageously Obliterated by Jay Dubya

Author Jay Dubya satirizes in adult language and content 18 popular O. Henry stories.  
Member BookAds

Life Culture Versus Death Culture and the Death of Literature! by Dr. Patrick ODougherty

If God is taken out of literature it becomes a death literature and a death of literature.  
Member BookAds

O. Henry: Obscenely and Outrageously Obliterated by Jay Dubya

Author Jay Dubya satirizes in adult language and content 18 popular O. Henry stories.  
Member BookAds