AuthorsDen.com   Join | Login    
Where Authors and Readers come together!

SIGNED BOOKS    AUTHORS    BOOKS    SAMPLE CHAPTERS    AUDIOBOOKS    eBOOKS    STORIES    ARTICLES    POETRY    BLOGS    NEWS    VIDEOS    SUCCESS    TESTIMONIALS

Featured Authors:  Charlene Proctor, iRochelle Brandon, iFERIAL Haque, iConnie Amarel, iSergio Serrano, Ph.D., iRaven West, iEmily Karlewicz, iWilliam Martell, iRachel Glasgow, iMORGAN ST. JAMES, i

  Home > Political Science > Articles Popular: Books, Stories, Articles, Poetry      Authors: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z     

J. W. Murphy

 Follow Me  

· Contact Me
· Articles
· Poetry
· Stories
· Messages
· 218 Titles
· 788 Reviews
· Save to My Library
· Share with Friends!
·
Member Since: Before 2003

J. W. Murphy, click here to update your pages on AuthorsDen!


Iraq, An Illegal War?
by J. W. Murphy   
Rated "G" by the Author.
     
Recent articles by
J. W. Murphy

• On the "Run of the Mill: A True Life, Napa Valley Adventure"
• Faith
• The Conversation
           >> View all

Relative perspective--I am all about putting things in historical and contextual perspective. I am not interested only in the now, I am interested in the then and the why and what went on then and how it relates to now.
Furthermore, I understand the UN's point on illegality but it is not the first time its desires have been ignored.



I’m confused.

I don’t understand how that the war in Iraq can be called an illegal war—perhaps one could make the argument that it is ill advised or perhaps not prudent but how may one say it is illegal? Especially for the Secretary-General of the UN to say: "I've indicated that it was not in conformity with the UN Charter from our point of view, and from the Charter point of view it was illegal" (September 15, 2004).

He also said he believed that there should have been a second resolution, post UN Resolution 1441, of November 8th, 2002, which states "that the Council has repeatedly warned Iraq that it will face serious consequences as a result of its continued violations of its obligations[.]" However, how many times must one pass a resolution and warn Iraq of "serious consequences" before actually delivering said "consequences"—how many time outs does it take?

When is credibility lost?

I am confused.

The UN fails to act and the United States, Great Britain, and Australia (among other nations) act and fulfill the affirmation of UN Resolution 1441 and that is illegal? So, is it better that one should wait around and give Saddam Hussein another second chance while he continues to defy the UN and all the Resolutions and treaties for twelve years?

Even more, the United States Congress authorized force in Iraq, as did the Parliament of Great Britain (Statements and Debates, 18 March 2003, cc760-901) in one sense to uphold the intent of the Resolutions on Iraq in light of the fact that a second "serious consequences" for non-compliance Resolution would not pass as France, a permanent member and a required vote, would veto it.

And, may I add, or rather quote, what the third paragraph of UN Resolution 1441 states: "Recognizing the threat Iraq’s non-compliance with Council resolutions and proliferation of weapons of mass destruction and long-range missiles poses to international peace and security"—apparently the UN also, and not only Congress and President Bush, felt that Iraq possessed "weapons of mass destruction."

So, how is this war illegal? The President of the United States was granted by Congress to use force, as was the Prime Minister of Great Britain by the Parliament of the United Kingdom, to carry out the warning of Resolution 1441 to the government of Saddam Hussein in lieu of the fact that France would not—while Saddam Hussein continued to "breach" the treaty his country made with the UN in allowing weapons inspectors in with full cooperation.

What really confuses me is how President Bush is being accused of waging an illegal war when he was given the approval of Congress to do so, unlike the President before him who launched "wars" in Haiti, Bosnia, and Kosovo without Congressional approval under the auspice of NATO (in the cases of Bosnia and Kosovo), without approval of the UN.

In other words, it was not illegal for President Clinton to wage pre-emptive wars without Congressional approval but it is illegal for President Bush to go to war with the approval of Congress?

I am confused.


Want to review or comment on this article?


Need a FREE Reader Membership?
Popular Political Science Articles
  1.  02 Substack Interviewed on Political P
  2.  Astrological Commentary On The 2016 El
  3.  We the Pimples... (or) a Child's Garde
  4.  Election Time USA and the Theatre of t
  5.  Fatuous Beyond Absurdity
  6.  A Thought Experiment About The Virus
  7.  Globalization
  8.  South Carolina’s Medicaid Travesty
  9.  Puppetmaster
  10.  Winners and Losers
  11.  U.S. Reliance on China’s Green Energy:
  12.  Danuta!
  13.  Whatever Happened to Journalistic Stan
  14.  A Scrappy Lot
  15.  A Special Invitation from Donald Trump
  16.  A Modest Proposal: Sharing Social Secu
  17.  When Trump Leaves
  18.  Exposing My Naivete
  19.  Fascism Loosely Defined for Current El
  20.  An Interesting experience AtThe Voting
  21.  No Kings Day
  22.  Fascism In A Nutshell
  23.  Cheney Has Failed Miserably
  24.  To Be A Patriot
  25.  When Trump Shakes Down the Media

Free Book Review Program
Select a book to read and review today!

A Guide to Chinese Affairs by Robert Liu

This is a political treatise that deals with the China issue from a completely new perspective. Disparaging as he may sound, from page to page, toward "the old system" and the Communist Party's various wiles, the author demonstrates his mysteriously  
Member BookAds

Free Download - Putin's Russia by Sam Vaknin

Russia's economy and politics under Vladimir Putin.  
Member BookAds

Be Afraid. Beaveree Eh Frayed v6 by RickthePoetWarrior

From the land of the milked and honeyed here’s a few political faux pas and a bit of attitude exposed to the harsh light of a Canadian who actually has their own opinion.  
Member BookAds