…By way of introduction to this ‘poem’ I must say that it only makes sense to me when seen from my particular chronology and bits of understanding. Life as I observe (and participate in) remains a complete enigma to me. I sense very deeply that I am supposed to ‘do’ something with it, and not just pass through as a tourist at a fair. I sense that I am expected (by whom?) to express responsibility within this life process—but how, and for what? The Teachers teach, they cannot answer these questions. Only I can.
I understand that for one’s life to develop meaningfully it must be guided. The guide is purpose. I must have purpose. If I am not given a purpose, or if the ‘purpose’ assigned to me, or forced upon me becomes a burden, or goes against my nature as an evolving and self-empowered ‘ISSA’ being, then I must change that purpose. I must create a whole new reason for expressing myself in such a way that it dovetails compassionately and creatively into other purposes also expressing the desire for meaning. I know what I want to say but my words are so inadequate to express the feeling.
To the poem, then.
Sha’Tara – December 12 th, 2008
Who Shall I Say?
[a poem from ~burning woman~ Sha’Tara ]
Who shall I say wrote and performed the music of the spheres
And who in a day painted the sea and the sky of earth?
And heaved up the green hills and rocky mountains
And ploughed out the canyons and misty valleys?
Who channeled the meandering rivers and cascading streams
And who planted the forests and the plains in their place?
And who peopled them with wildlife, insects fish and birds?
Who shall I say did all this just to set it free to grow at will?
Which of all the answers given
Shall I say is the right one?
Was it man’s creators?
Was it man’s slaves?
Was it man?
Who shall I say forms the tools and builds the great ships
And who sails the oceans of the world and flies the skies?
And who sends the mighty armies to conquer and plunder?
And who carves out the roads and expands the bloody cities?
Who shall I say writes the great symphonies and tells the stories
And who plays out the sad romances and pain-filled dramas?
And who looks on the sun and the moon and the stars in hope?
Who shall I say dies a million and one times alone on the shore?
Which of all the answers given
Shall I say is the right one?
Is it man’s creators?
Is it man’s slaves?
Is it man?
Who shall I say will dream crystal palaces adorning domed cities
And who will walk the future to encounter the peace weavers?
And who will open her arms to sweep up a giggling child at play?
And who without fear will touch another in holy reverence?
Who shall I say will set the notes of love in man’s new song
And who will capture energy strands from a billion alien stars?
And who will stand at the head of the silently gathered ones?
Who shall I say will have authority to give the signal for departure?
Which of all the answers possible
Shall I say is the right one?
Will it be man’s creators?
Will it be man’s slaves?
Will it be man?
It's wonderful to see you branching out from articles alone lately, with short stories and poetry. I like the searching, questioning format of this piece - it represents Man's attitude in general; seeking answers ever after. Fantastic! Love and Hugs,
Sheila
...you have well written...questions that will perhaps continue to be raised...and perhaps we all seek our own answers within.
giving us reason to think...thank you Regis...
John
Thank you for this preamble and poem Regis. All the important questions are contemplated here. It is such a struggle to live with a sense of having no purpose. I was there for many years.
Blessings J'nia
Probably, most of us live through our lifetime trying to discover the purpose for our being born, if any. Its hard to accept though that there is none. As usual, deep thoughts, Reg. Thanks for the challenging article. Love and Blessings to you my friend.
I believe everyone has a purpose for living that only they can find and I propose that the bonding of our consciences to our hearts is the only way we can find it.
Every man devises an answer in his heart--but it is the Universe that speaks for us all. "The One Who Is" has done this! The One who is above all and beyond all. The One is is Over All and In All. The One Who Is... It is of Him that you write dear friend. You have answered many questions with yet aanother question. I know of Another who did so. Perhaps you have learned from Him.
Sort of reminds me of "He knows not what he does"... the way people just keep on doing and .... wondering "why"... when... he/they/we/you are the answer! mistakes can be avoided...can be learned from.. really thoughtful write... lindalaw
unlike the lyrics of "Who Will Answer", "the answer is blowing in the wind" -- the answer is there and here and everywhere -- if we seek omnipotence, surely we will not seek man -- for just how gross is the ignorance of man, the evidence is strewn about every environ he has touched -- the slaves of man certainly can bear no greater intelligence than their captors, nay only less or there would not be slaves -- we seek the answer only out of our insecurities -- for all these things were given to us by He that created all -- peace and love to you my friend -- JMW
Reviewed by Stan Grimes (Reader)
Reviewed on December 13, 2008
Well expressed Reg. A question that will plague humankind forever. Or, perhaps the answer will plague us eternally.
The Double Mirrors and Ones and Zeros theories, by Dylan Tauber. Parallel mirrors in our minds produce a vision of the infinite. Love is all that exists. Free PDF download.
This book presents a narrative story of one person's journey of transcendental Awakening and Enlightenment as guided by his two Sage companions. It is grounded in Zen Buddhist and Taoist perspective and uses the I Ching as its structural framework. T
This book chronicles an infinite allegoric odyssey of Absolute Awakening in which a learned man, a mute man, and a recluse woman are the principal players. The mute and the recluse are the learned one's Teachers and Guides on his journey of Enlighten
This is a question that will forever afflict human race
This poem is food for thought
Brilliant write
Wishing you simple pleasures,
Memorable moments,
And a Christmas
That warms your Heart,
Peace love and Light...And hugsss…….Morning Star
"Who Shall I Say?" is fantastic my friend!!
Always the Best,
Lance
Sheila
giving us reason to think...thank you Regis...
John
Love TinkaSweets
Blessings J'nia
Sincerely,
Regino
great write,
Pierre
Thank you for sharing,
Linda
Best regards,
Leland