As an author and a book reviewer I’ve been on both sides of the fence when it comes to book reviewing, and believe me I’ve seen the best and worst of attempts to review a book. It’s very important if you want to review books to follow certain criteria if you want to be successful at it and have both authors and other book reviewers respect your work. The following are some tips to keep in mind when reviewing someone’s book:
Remember the book you are reading or have read is someone’s baby, keep in mind how you would feel if someone denigrated your child in front of you. Be kind even when being critical.
Be objective. Don’t let your book review become a personal attack against the author. If you don’t like the book say why but keep your comments focused on specifics such as for example, the hero’s personality seemed in conflict with his actions.
Don’t just say what you don’t like, say what you do like.
Don’t be a spoiler, meaning don’t give away secrets from the book. Give an overview of what the book is about during your beginning paragraphs only, without giving away significant details which will be revealed later in the book.
Be prepared for the possibility the author of a book from a less than glowing review may contact you and be upset. People are human and while you know you’ve been objective there’s still a possibility the author may attempt to change your mind. Be firm, but be kind. You don’t want to alienate anyone, but neither do you have to change your mind.
Above all, have fun! As an author I enjoy reading reviews done for my books as it lets me know both where I’ve done well and where I might need some work. As a reviewer it’s fun because I get to help other authors in the same way.
If you keep these tips in mind when reviewing someone’s book you will have a better chance at both being a successful reviewer and at having fun while you do so.
As a fellow reviewer I can honestly say you hit the nail on the head.
I read one book that was so bad I declined to do the review because I couldn't say anything good enough about it to prompt people to spend the money on it.
I followed the same rules you listed for the last 20 odd years of reviewing.
I hope the readers of this article will read mine on How to Get a Good Book Review.
As a fellow reviewer I can honestly say you hit the nail on the head.
I read one book that was so bad I declined to do the review because I couldn't say anything good enough about it to prompt people to spend the money on it.
I followed the same rules you listed for the last 20 odd years of reviewing.
I hope the readers of this article will read mine on How to Get a Good Book Review.
Bobbi