Mohamed Nabil
Category:
Philosophy
Type: Non-Fiction
Pages: 419
Copyright: May 22, 2026
ISBN-13: 9798198122703
Price: FREE! (eBook)
AIDOP stands for AI Debates on One's Publications, a framework that I created and first applied in Philosophical Debates with AI.
AIDOP stands for AI Debates on One’s Publications, it is a framework that I created for content creation to stress-test ideas through AI, invite readers to explore the mechanisms of the thought process, sharpen ideas by responding to criticism, refine one’s own thoughts, document where AI tools stand at the time of publication, and turn content into living texts instead of closed chapters.
The methodology involves asking an AI tool to criticize one of your own publications or take a position opposing to yours, engaging in back-and-forth argumentation, and copying the entire unedited transcript within 24 hours of the exchange.
Along the way, one may simply accept criticism as valid or agree to disagree on certain issues.
This book includes a selection of essays from the blog section of my website; the essays are paired together based on their themes, starting with an essay that tackles a certain topic, followed by an essay which involves me debating an AI tool over the same topic after prompting it to criticize the content of the initial essay.
Essays in this book tackle the absurdity of nationalism, a manifesto for the fictional Global Justice Party, the fact that global justice and unity can limit future pandemics, the controversies surrounding the Global Justice Novel, My Interview with ChatGPT Book, Enlightened Populism Book, and The Bachelors of Egypt Novel… the philosophical roots for The Bachelors of Egypt, corporate life and politics, Mohamed Mahmoud Incidents, the 2011 Egyptian revolution or uprising, the explanation of Enlightened Populism, and debates on book samples of three of my previous books.
The ideas in this book have been scrutinized by leading Large Language Models like ChatGPT and Gemini, AIDOP was never intended to replace human debate, feel free to share your views on the book’s content.
Excerpt
Ideas that Survived AIDOP
(AI Debates on One’s Publications)
Intro:
I created AI Debates on One’s Publications (AIDOP) by using AI tools to conduct debates on my own published books; The Bachelors of Egypt, Enlightened Populism: Reflections on the News Cycle of a Pandemic, My Interview with ChatGPT and Global Justice and published the whole exchanges in a book titled Philosophical Debates with AI published in 27 January 2026
I used the same approach to conduct debates with AI tools on my previously published essays and published the whole exchanges under a category in my blog titled Philosophical Debates with AI, along with the book’s sample.
My debates with AI tools in the book tackled Enlightened Populism, Radical Globalism, Corporate Corruption, Global Justice, Moral Universality, Activism, the role of AI in future societies, the practicality of establishing a single world government with equal rights for all citizens and critiques of The Bachelors of Egypt novel’s philosophical premise and “My Interview with ChatGPT” book… the blog posts under the mentioned category naturally tackled more topics extensively.
My own use tackled my own areas of interest; Philosophy, Politics, Sociology, Psychology, Economics… yet the method can be adopted across several fields causing serious disruption to how content is published and how readers interact.
Purpose:
The goal of these debates isn’t to “win” or “lose”, the main objectives include stress-testing ideas through AI; effectively making them sharper by responding to criticism, refining one’s own thoughts, simply accepting criticism as valid or agreeing to disagree on certain points… inviting readers to explore the mechanisms of the thought process instead of simply asking them to accept conclusions, and documenting where AI tools stand at the time of publication. AIDOP effectively turns your work into living texts with open discussions instead of closed chapters.
The method encourages Enlightened Populism:
As highlighted in my essay Enlightened Populism Explained, Enlightened populism is presented as a healthy alternative to the two dominant behavioral patterns of communication in today’s world, “Blind Elitism” and “Ignorant Populism”; it may help provide the essential infrastructure for human beings to dismantle tribalism, cronyism, polarization, toxic competitiveness, oppression, systemic bigotry…
Blind Elitism involves blindly following a certain "expert" or an "elite" without investigating the information, Ignorant Populism also involves the absence of investigation while relying on feelings or trends. Enlightened Populism involves listening to multiple experts, trying to understand how they reached certain conclusions and investigating the information to discern the truth.
By inviting readers to the thought process while presenting arguments and counter arguments, the content creator effectively encourages them to act as Enlightened Populists.
Radical Transparency: Instead of using AI for ghost writing which I consider as unethical as hiring a human ghost writer, or refining thoughts behind closed doors, you can invite readers to your own lab while demonstrating that your ideas can survive scrutiny.
Methodology:
1. You start by asking the AI tool to take a position opposing to yours, for example you can ask the tool to criticize your own published works or ask it if a certain disruptive idea of yours is applicable.
2. You engage in back-and-forth argumentation with the AI tool.
3. You copy-paste the whole conversation without editing anything (or narrate it fully for video/audio content).
4. For free publicly available content like blog articles and essays, you should copy-paste the whole content while asking the AI tool to take an opposing position. For content existing behind a paywall like books and academic papers, you can choose whether to provide the whole content to the AI tool or let it rely on publicly available data points to form its initial response.
5. Publish the content within 24 hours of the exchange, to effectively document where one or multiple AI tools stand at the time of publication.
Recommended AI tools:
Based on my own experience the best sparring partners today among the publicly available AI tools are ChatGPT and Gemini.
Adoption process:
To encourage the adoption of AIDOP, I will personally promote any content created using the described methodology through my blog and/or social media, as long as it mentions me and AIDOP while linking to this webpage: https://mohamednabil.world/aidop
This book includes a selection of essays from the blog section of my website https://mohamednabil.world/blog the essays are paired together based on their themes, starting with an essay that tackles a certain topic, followed by an essay which involves me debating an AI tool over the same topic after prompting it to criticize the content of the initial essay.
The essays are:
1
- A- The Absurdity of Nationalism: The Bachelors of Egypt
B- The Absurdity of Nationalism: Philosophical Debates with AI
2
- A- Global Justice Party Manifesto 2026
B- Philosophical Debates with AI: Global Justice Party Manifesto
3
- A- Global Justice Can Limit Future Pandemics
B- Philosophical Debates with AI: Global Justice Can Limit Pandemics
4
- A- The Controversy Surrounding Global Justice
B- Global Justice Controversy: Philosophical Debates with AI
5
- A- The Controversy Surrounding My Interview with ChatGPT
B- My Interview with ChatGPT: Philosophical Debates with AI
6
- A- The Controversy Surrounding Enlightened Populism
B- Enlightened Populism Controversy: Philosophical Debates with AI
7
- A- The Controversy Surrounding The Bachelors of Egypt Novel
B- The Bachelors of Egypt Controversy: Philosophical Debates with AI
8
- A- Philosophical Legacy: The Bachelors of Egypt
B- Philosophical Legacy: Philosophical Debates with AI
9
- A- Corporate Life and Politics: The Bachelors of Egypt
B- Corporate Life and Politics: Philosophical Debates with AI
10
- A- Mohamed Mahmoud Incidents: The Bachelors of Egypt
B- Mohamed Mahmoud Incidents: Philosophical Debates with AI
11
- A- 2011 Egyptian Revolution: The Bachelors of Egypt
B- 2011 Egyptian Revolution: Philosophical Debates with AI
12
- A- The Bachelors of Egypt (essay)
B- The Bachelors of Egypt: Philosophical Debates with AI
13
- A- The Bachelors of Egypt Novel Sample
B- The Bachelors of Egypt Book Sample: Philosophical Debates with AI
14
- A- My Interview with ChatGPT Book Sample
B- Philosophical Debates with AI: My Interview with ChatGPT Sample
15
- A- Enlightened Populism Book Sample
B- Philosophical Debates with AI: Enlightened Populism Book Sample
16
- A- Enlightened Populism Explained
B- Philosophical Debates with AI: Enlightened Populism Explained
|
