The U.S.war in Iraq is a tragic blunder that is costing lives and money. It is a war of deception and is failing in leadership and accountability.
- Four years since the U.S. invasion, the mission in Iraq has become a fight against an inexhaustible insurgency emboldened by the U.S. presence.
- The Iraq war is spending lives. As of April 1, 2008 4,011 U.S. troops have died and over 29,496 have been wounded. On average a thousand innocent Iraqis die each month. Between 151,000 to 665,000 Iraqi civilians have died since the war began four years ago.
- More than one in four U.S. soldiers come home from Iraq with health problems.
- The American soldiers and their families bear most of the burden of the war.
- Every second America stays in Iraq we taxpayers pay $6,300. Several studies suggest the tab could be between $1 to $2 trillion. This does not include the medical and disability costs to American veterans with injuries.
- President Bush is hobbled by and the rising gas prices and the budget deficit.
- America is borrowing the money from China and other countries to finance the war. We add $200 billion every year the troops remain in Iraq. The vast sums of money going to Iraq would be better spent rescuing the American health care and school system, developing alternative forms of energy and reducing poverty.
- Instead of going after Osama bin Laden, al Qaeda, and the Saudi extremist after September 11, 2001 the Bush Administration chose to invade oil rich Iraq, a country that had nothing to do with the U.S attack.
- Many people believe the Bush Administration invaded Iraq to eliminate the need to continue the The United States-Saudi Arabia Joint Economic Commission (JEOR) with The House of Saud, the rulers of Saudi Arabia.
- The war on terror is being lost because Al Queda’s real motive for attacking America is about U.S. policies not about hating "democratic freedoms." The policies include America’s unqualified support for Israel, the U.S troops on the Arabian Peninsula, forcing below market prices in Muslim oil, the protection of corrupt Muslin regimes and the occupation of Iraq and Afghanistan.
- Bush Administration intended to get America into a war with Iraq eight months before the 9/11 attacks. Richard Clark, President Bush’s former top anti-terrorist advisor, Paul O’Neill, the former National Security Council member and the British Downing Street Memo said it was not a question of "why" but "how."
- Civil war is not inevitable if a good leader offers the Iraqi citizens peace and prosperity. Although the ratio of blacks to whites in South Africa is five to one the world incorrectly predicted a civil war when blacks were allowed to vote and Nelson Mandela, the first black Prime Minister, was elected in 1994.
- Iraq’s civil war will continue whether our troops withdraw tomorrow or ten years from now.
- Only about five percent of the terrorists in Iraq are foreign suicide bombers the others are Iraqis. The Sunnis, the former ruling minority that forms 20% of the Iraq population, are the warriors and have the power to maintain violence indefinitely.
- The proposed Iraq constitution creates autonomous regions for the Kurds and Shi’ites in the oil-rich north and south leaving the Sunnis without natural resources like oil.
- There were no documented suicide attacks in Iraq before the American invasion in 2003. Only when the U.S. stops using Iraq as a battleground and requires our occupation forces to leave will peace be possible in Iraq. (President Bush said rather there than here.)
- The Iraqi opposition is sacrificing themselves to defend their country while America is sacrificing its soldiers for oil, which is what the war is about.
- The war is not winnable militarily.
- A July 2007 poll shows that seventy-one percent of Americans support the removal of all U.S. troops from Iraq by April 1, 2008.
- The Bush Administration set a precedent after 227 years to invade a country that had not attacked us first.
- America dominates the nuclear and military arena because of its 10,000 nuclear warheads and stockpiles of weapons.
- Both Iraq and America have a history of ethnic cleansing, slavery, civil war and withholding the vote from woman.
- Democracy in the U.S. is declining as it becomes an increasingly repressive empire in the service of corporate interests.
- The U.S. Equal Rights Amendment has yet to be ratified by the legislators for voting and inclusion in the Constitution.
- There was an intelligence failure—the Bush administration failed to learn that Saddam had no weapons of mass destruction.
- The Bush administration made a mistake not thwarting the Iraqi insurgency at its start.
- The Iraq invasion failed because the borders were not secured, there were too few U.S. troops and the Iraqi army was disbanded creating 400,000 disgruntled unemployed soldiers and civil servants.
- More Jihades are recruited than being killed because of insufficient troops, equipment, resources and frequent troop replacement.
- There is no plausible road map towards stability in Iraq.
- We don’t have enough intelligence analysts.
- We have a weak counterinsurgency plan. Experts in counterinsurgency warfare say killing insurgents only increases recruits and alienates civilians. A proven method to gain an intelligence advantage is to protect civilians by providing safe havens with military, economic and political security.
- The army and marines are stretched to breaking point.
- There is a failure of leadership and lack of accountability in the U.S. military. As of October 2005 the Army has investigated more than 400 allegation of prisoner abuse, similar to the Abu Ghraib scandal, in Iraq and Afghanistan. More than 230 of its personnel have been court-martialed or received non-judicial punishment.
- Hurricane Katrina showed Americas rescue capabilities are extremely limited in natural and man-made disasters.
- The Katrina aftermath exposed how the Bush Administration puts political connections before experience in some top vital government positions and awards contracts to companies with strong ties.
- Natural disasters were neglected when State and Federal government shifted its money and manpower to the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.
- The Federal and local government’s slow response to the Hurricane Karina victims cost lives and showed the need to address America’s poverty, deteriorating infrastructure and environmental degradation.
- The emphasis on the war in Iraq and terrorism has hurt the Federal Emergency Management Agency FEMA when it was subsumed by the Department of Homeland Security.
- The U.S. Federal and Local government left half-a-million hurricane victims to fend for themselves for six days in New Orleans in September 2005.
- America is focused on risk rather than disaster prevention. For example from 2001 to 2005 the Corps asked Congress for $496 million to upgrade and improve levees, drainage and pumping stations in New Orleans. Congress approved only $249.5million—half of what the Corps wanted.
- Congress approved $62.3 billion in Gulf Coast aid for FEMA. The final tab could top $200 billion.
- Most of the Jihades are young Saudis who are inflamed by America’s foreign policies and the footage of fighting and prisoner abuse in Iraq.
- The U.S. economy benefits from the Iraq war as the contracts to rebuild Iraq have been given to U.S. companies such as Bechtel and Halliburton
- The training of the Iraqi forces is ineffective.
- The Bush administration should stop fighting the press and Democrats and figure out how to end the war in Iraq.
- The U.S war in Iraq is a tragic blunder that is costing lives and money. It is a war of deception and is failing in leadership and accountability.
- The U.S. should apply the right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness to all people of the world not just Americans as history shows that communism and terrorism are predictable reactions to oppression and exploitation.
SUPPORT THE TROOPS: BRING THEM HOME!
|
Coming into the war we may have not been correct and completely justified according to just war theory. Our reasons for going to war clearly were not what we thought they were prior to the invasion. I also agree that America likely did not have completely right intentions in going, as we may have been more motivated by emotions then for a true care for the Iraqi citizen. Americans were under the impression that Iraq had weapons of mass destruction that could attack us with ease, and that Iraq’s government was aiding al-Qaeda. Once the fact that neither of these ideas about Iraq were true our leaders still decided to entire Iraq believing that they still had a right to do so. We can look back now and know that we may not have been completely justified in entering Iraq.
I also completely understand that we did not follow the second tenet of just war theory and strive to be just and have just conduct during the war. It was apparent throughout the conflict that we were not able to keep all of the actions of war away from non-combatants. Many of the things that Americans were a part of during the conflict was horrible in nature and I will not argue that. A mere mention of Abu Gharib and we are reminded of how quickly we can turn from a force that is helping people and being the good guys, into looking an awful lot like the bad guys. We have committed crimes against the people of Iraq and have failed to help many of the people that we have swore to support and defend by going over there in the first place.
It is hard to swallow such statements, especially knowing that people who we love have gone over and participated in the fight. Some of which have even been wounded and even died for the cause. It is with this in mind that I urge you to not just let the fact that we have made errors in the past sway you to advocate for rash decisions in Iraq.
As our leadership makes important decisions in regards to what will be going on in Iraq in the near future we must let them know that although we have messed up in the past prior to entering the war and even during the conflict we must not pull out prematurely and leave Iraq in an even worse situation then they are in now.
We should be looking toward ways to try and make up for the errors that we have committed in the past. If there is any way that we can support Iraq and bring them back into a state that they were in prior to our invasion then we would likely be able to leave the war in a more just manner. No doubt we have already begun to restore Iraq and have helped to bring stability to their economy, school systems, and even form of government. We ridded the country of an evil dictator and have brought them democracy and the American way of life. We have allowed women rights that they have not seen in the past and have allowed the people of Iraq to live lives that would have been impossible under Saddam’s dictatorship.
We must however finish what we have begun in the country and try to make up for the errors that we have committed in Iraq. Let us band together and inform our leaders that no matter how much we would love to have our family and friends home and back with us, that we would much rather give back to the people of Iraq what we have taken from them without just cause.
Let us not look at the quickest way to exit the country and make a situation that is already bad, just a little bit worse. We must urge everyone we know to support our troops as they try to do the right thing and restore Iraq and build it back up to an even greater status then it was when we first invaded the country in two thousand three. Lets decide that no matter how hard it may be for us to have people that we love in other countries that we would rather leave the war in a just and admirable manner then we have conducted ourselves in, in the past.
We should look at the newly added third tenet of the just war theory and know that we do need to exit the country, as our goals that we were trying to accomplish in the country (stop al-Qaeda, and remove weapons of mass destruction) have become impossible to accomplish as neither of them is actually a problem in the region. We should though however remember that in every action we take now we must remain just and correct as we are still occupying their country.
We should continue to aid the Iraqi people in any and everyway possible and support them until they are completely stable and able to take complete care of themselves. Once this is clearly the case for the people of Iraq then we can bring our men and women home, and at least end this war in a just manner.
You have presented us with facts. Please keep writing so the ignorant can be educated.
Love & Light always and in all ways,
Joseph*
The war on Iraq has fueled terrorism
Pray to God that with the tragic situataion in the Middle East, the war doesn't spread any further
I salute you, Niki
Love and peace
Huda
Having said that, I would like to address a few of the points made in your article:
#14. We don't know who blew up the Twin Towers and blamed it on the Arabs, although Marvin Bush comes up because he was in charge of security and allegedly planted the bombs the day before when the power went out for an hour. The Air Force shot down the 4th plane after passengers took it back from the skyjackers; that suggests CIA complicity. Israeli agents were filming the Twin Towers attacks as they happened and alarmed witnesses who mistook those MOSSAD folks for Arabs. Usamah bin Ladin said he didn't know who did the attacks in his first and only authentic video - "one of America's many enemies" he said. Even bin Ladin didn't know it was a CIA and/or MOSSAD stitch job. (see Griffin's "The New Pearl Harbor" for leftist views and www.americanfreepress.net for rightist views, both alleging our government was behind the 9/11 "Reichstag fires".
#16. Al Qaydah is known to Muslims and non-Muslims through media accounts. Without the media accounts, they are unknown. Because Muslims have never heard of Al Qaydah, the question arises - who is Al Qaydah? Many suspect that they are CIA providing a bogeyman to justify U.S./U.K. aggression.
#26. The invasion of Iraq is not a precedent. Granada was invaded and the government overthrown in 1983 for the "sin" of voting a socialist into office as president.
#31. There was no intelligence failure; Bush wanted excuses to go to war and the British manufactured them accordingly (see www.ImpeachBlair.org).
#32. The U.S. and U.K. governments have been bombing the Iraqi Sons of Liberty monthly for the past 14 years. Clinton bombed them monthly all eight years of his terms, and Bush has continued the monthly bombings. The British drop bombs on them too. Whether it is to prop up a dictatorship or to prop up a sham democracy, U.S. bombs kill Iraqis.
#36. Intelligence and surveillance of Iraq and Afghanistan is amazingly thorough. AWACS and satellite support watches everything. The Brits are there as well as a U.N. coalition. The Iraqi government was overthrown so quickly because of this.
#42. Rather than being a tragic blunder, the U.S./U.K. invasion of Iraq with United Nations support has been successful. The sham democracy is in place. Like the sham republic installed in Iran in 1980 that continues until today, the sham democracy in Iraq will prove just as resilient. Corporations will own everything there instead of the people, and the people will waste their time and energy through the political process to achieve voice. (www.poclad.org)
www.VeteransForPeace.org
By disregarding United nations and World opinion, the US also sullied its reputation as the leader of the free world. One just hopes that innocent American citizens do not suffer as a result of this in the future.