Join Free! | Login 

   Popular! Books, Stories, Articles, Poetry
Where Authors and Readers come together!

Signed Bookstore | Authors | eBooks | Books | Stories | Articles | Poetry | Blogs | News | Events | Reviews | Videos | Success | Gold Members | Testimonials

Featured Authors: Sage Sweetwater, iBob Mitchley, iSteve Kerr, iAlfred Schwab, iSusan Rempel, iPeter Ralph, iDiana Perkins, i
  Home > Literary Criticism > Articles
Popular: Books, Stories, Articles, Poetry     

Ian Irvine (Hobson)

  + Follow Me   

· 139 titles
· 89 Reviews
· Share with Friends!
· Save to My Library
Member Since: Before 2003

   My Blog
   Contact Author
   Read Reviews

Subscribe to the Ian Irvine (Hobson) Newsletter. Enter your name and email below and click "sign me up!"

· Dream-Dust Parasites

· The Angel of Luxury and Sadness, Volume One

· Facing The Demon of noontide

Short Stories
· The Orpheus Plague

· The Phantom Library

· Theresa Jones - by Ian Irvine (hobson)

· The Doubtful Muse - by Ian Irvine (Hobson)

· Samuel Elmsmore Dreams of Harry The Crab

· Five Boxes and a Knife

· Trevor Franklin Refuses to Allow me to Impress my Teacher

· New Science Perspectives on Ghosts and Other Paranormal Phenomena

· Sara Douglass, Speculative Fiction & Medieval History

· Transmedia Story-Telling (in a Holographic Multiverse)

· Zoetics: New Perspectives on Fundamental Creativity

· Muse of the Long-Haul: Thirty-One Isles of the Creative Imagination

· Trickster Gods and the Quantum Muse: Creativity and the Multiverse

· Hermesian Epidemics: Depression, Anxiety, Derealisation, Narcissism ,

· Hermes Negatively Polarised - Pt 5 Alchemy and the Imagination

· The Angel of Luxury and Sadness

· Notes on Creativity Revolutions: Modernism - A Literature of the Void?

· Hermapolis: Thoth and Ma'at Assist the Time Travellers

· Hiroshima Dance

· Three Poems in Platform 15

· Any Available Exit

· Spirits in Triples

· Tending the Grove - from the Taliesin-Ceridwen Sequence

· The Chase Across time (part 2)

· The Chase Across Time (Part 1)

· The World Rushed in (The Awen)

· Three Drops From the Cauldron

         More poetry...
· Hermes, Thoth and Seshat: (Un)Heralded Gods of the Postmodern Transition

· Aradale Creativity Weekend

· The Gods Abandon Olympus (for Hollywood) - Public Talk

· Sara Douglass Worlds - Revived

· Bendigo Writers Festival 2014

· An Accidental Soldier (based on Silent Parts by John Charalambous)

· Voyage of the Beagle poems at

Ian Irvine (Hobson), click here to update your web pages on AuthorsDen.

Books by Ian Irvine (Hobson)
Meditations on the crisis engulfing the flagship Australian literary journal Meanjin.

I was first alerted to the news that Sophie Cunningham had resigned as Meanjin editor late last week after reading an article in the Melbourne Age newspaper by Peter Craven, a renowned Australian writer and cultural figure. Whilst I am not party to the details of what has unfolded between Cunningham (who has been an excellent, innovative editor ) and Melbourne University over the future of the publication - and thus will refrain from commenting on the politics of what has unfolded there -  I do think it is clear that what is happening to Meanjin has profound symbolic dimensions related to the ways in which ideas/critique etc. are transmitted to audiences in the new 'digital and print' publishing world.

Quite apart from Craven's comments re: the intricate political situation at Melbourne University (embroiling it seems MUP), his article was extremely dismissive of the 'web' - terms such as 'arid desert' and '[im]permanent' were (as I recall) used. The unexamined assumption seemed to be that the WWW in no sense allows for sustained intellectual examination of cultural phenomena in the way, say that Meanjin and other flagship Australian literary journals have done for so many years.

This tack, from such a leading Australian literary figure, left me with ambivalent feelings - indeed the article itself represented both the strengths and the weaknesses of figures deeply embedded in the old 'print' paradigm now under such sustained pressure from what we may term the new 'digital' paradigm represented by the world wide web, e-book devices, POD books, global distribution systems, online bookshops, etc. etc.

From my perspective the technology of writing has been undergoing a profound revolution these past twenty or so years, and, as McLuhan pointed out so many decades ago, every new media brings with it new ways of viewing the world - new paradigms, new ways of thinking, new ways of encountering artefacts and culture generally. More importantly, once a population shifts decisively to embrace new media forms it becomes the job of artists, thinkers, writers etc. to keep up as best they can. There is no going back on the digital publishing revolution, there is no ignoring now the vast new literary world opened up to 'writers' and contributors to cultural commentary as a result of these new technologies - no going back to the more centralised, localised, perhaps personality driven, book (print) based 'culture' that founded Australia as a nation (after the invasion of Aboriginal lands).

The digital revolution certainly has its problems - oligarchic and monopolistic elements in the IT world ... the monopolistic impulses represented by search engines and online bookshops ... the speeed of change (digital file formats mutating at speed, reader device monopolies, etc ) ... the amount of 'information noise' ... the phenomenon of 'flitting' rather than reading deeply ... the hyper-capitalism apparently implicit to the new media ... consciousness dispersal ... problems with uninformed cultural democracy (drowning out 'the more informed (best/specialist?) minds') etc. During such a period of transition it is natural to be concerned as key institutions once charged with maintaining 'civil society' start to topple in quick succession: print journals today, print publishers (as traditional gate-keepers) tomorrow, newspapers the day after, universities (at least in their traditional form) the day after that ... All these traditional cultural regulators/ mediators/ gatekeepers are either disappearing, being marginalised or being completely transformed as I write.

I suspect that Peter Craven, along with other members of Australia's established print-based intelligentsia, know only too well that the death or transformation of Meanjin signals the beginning of the end for the social pact that allowed certain people to act as representatives of disciplines like literature, social commentary, etc. and the greater public (and for many decades). Like Craven, I'm concerned that new institutions capable of focusing a community's attention on important social and cultural issues have not yet developed (or proven themselves) as examples of a new and effective pact between the new intellectual (making use of the new digital media) and the new 'public'. Unlike Craven, however, I don't think there's too much point in lamenting excessively over what has passed - there is simply too much to do. It is precisely the job of writers and intellectuals concerned at the social instabilities potentially accompanying the cultural, and ultimately cognitive, changes associated with the 'new media', to work diligently to ensure that the changes work to promote and nurture 'civil society', human rights etc..  

As I see it at present, the verdict is still out as to whether the new writing technologies will become tools for furthering human rights agendas, or weapons in the arsenal of a futuristic Orwellian dictatorship ... There is no time to lose: the new literature, and the new audience for the new literature exists ... for better or worse all writers contribue these days to a global 'supermind', a kind of 'meme organism' ... i.e. the ultimate mutation of the technologies of writing and communicating that were once under the dominion of deities such as Thoth, Nabu, Hermes, Mercury, etc.

 To read Peter Craven's arcticle go to: Meanjin 2011?


Want to review or comment on this article?
Click here to login!

Need a FREE Reader Membership?
Click here for your Membership!

Popular Literary Criticism Articles
  1. Analysis of The Mexican Swimmer by Adam Si
  2. The Hand of Christ book review
  3. The Murder of King Tut by James Patterson
  4. As Do You Really Read News...
  5. Book Titles Which Caught My Eye ...
  6. Quest for the Secret Keeper
  7. Dark Prophecy, A Level 26 Thriller book re
  8. Didactic Fiction
  9. A Professional Review
  10. 3 H - P 10

You can also search authors by alphabetical listing: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Featured Authors | New to AuthorsDen? | Add AuthorsDen to your Site
Share AD with your friends | Need Help? | About us

Problem with this page?   Report it to AuthorsDen

AuthorsDen, Inc. All rights reserved.