AuthorsDen.com  Join | Login 

 
Where Authors and Readers come together!

Authors | Books | Audiobooks | eBooks | Signed Bookstore | Stories | Articles | Poetry | Blogs | News | Events | Reviews | Videos | Success | Gold Members | Testimonials

Featured Authors:  D. Enise, iJames Hill, iLisa DAnnolfo Levey, iJeff Ovall, iStephen Murray, iSam Vaknin, iT. Cline, iGlen Schulz, iFrank Ryan, iD.E.Z. Butler, i

  Home > Essays > Articles
Popular: Books, Stories, Articles, Poetry      Authors: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z     

David Arthur Walters

 Follow Me  

· 678 titles
· 780 Reviews
· Share with Friends!
· Save to My Library
·
Member Since: Sep, 2004

   Sitemap
   My Blog
   Contact Author
   Read Reviews




Short Stories
· The Brazen Harlot from The Seed that Fell on Rocky Ground

· The Brazen Harlot from The Seed that Fell on Rocky Ground

· Review of David Arthur Walters' book MY HAWAII

· Converting Gaza Justly Recommended to President Trump

· Donalde Creates Devil's Advocate Office

· Wrecked by Success or Successful Loser?

· Animal Rights Protest South Beach

· Tracey's Secret

· My Take On Needle Park

· Machines and Me


Articles
· Iran Intervention: Diplomacy vs. Force & Bowling Balls

· The Curse of the South Beach Iguans

· Accounts Payable - My Life Past Due

· FASCES by David Arthur Walters Reviewed

· Lucila Gonzalez flew with her pole!

· Moral Virtue vs Practical Wisdom

· Moral Virtue vs Practical Wisdom

· Dr, Jill Flanders Crosby Commendation with Punkmodern Dance Reference

· We Fondly Remember Booknook's Kimberly Hitch Hitchens

· Kill The Cockroaches - A Bestseller?


Poetry
· My Dear Loving Friend

· Mother Charlotte Watches Over Us Still

· Sisyphus

· Certainly Heroes Must Exist

· What Hath God Wrought?

· Shekhinah

· Derridada

· St. Louis Arch

· Follow Your Heart

· My Cold Dutch Wife

         More poetry...
News
· Jihad Book by David Arthur Walters Reviewed

· Random Ramblings by David Arthur Walters reviewed

· Review of The Compassionate Heart of America by David Arthur Walters

· Wake Up World Before It Is Too Late

· Death Penality Recommended for Guilty Healthcare Officials

· Former Hawaii Attorney General Opinion: on Climate Change Suits

· Tracey's South Beach Secret Released!

David Arthur Walters, click here to update your web pages on AuthorsDen.

The Romantic Scientific Fallacy
by David Arthur Walters
Last edited: Friday, August 3, 2007
Posted: Wednesday, February 28, 2007



     
Back to Africa

The struggle for existence between tribe and tribe depends on the advance in the moral and intellectual quality of its members. Sigmund Freud

 

 

Beware, the forces that caused Hitler are not dead - they are in our midst - we blame our leaders too much for the little Hitler in us. The issue is not race in the biological sense. It never has been.

 

Robert Ardrey, author of African Genesis, summed up 'The Romantic Fallacy' thus: "The romantic fallacy may be defined as the central conviction of modern thought that all human behavior, with certain clearly stated exceptions, results from causes lying within the human experience."

 

The romantic fallacy is derived from the egoistic illusion of centrality: that the world and each human inhabitant or family or tribe or clan or race or nation or state thereon are at the center of the universe; further, that the human being can know himself or god and therefore the universe - egoistic notions of internal and external reality allegedly disproved by Galileo and Freud.

 

We know our experiences. If knowledge of causes is power over effects, and if man can know everything, then he can be omnipotent in fact and in fact return to the original good or oceanic milk-paradise of the omnipotent, born-again babe, where he will no longer encounter any resistance to arouse his anger, hatred, and strategic hate-based love. Never mind that in reality if not in his imagination man has proven himself to be a war-mongering carnivore obsessed with personal status and private wealth. Never mind that he is more of an animal than a god. Never mind that his high civilization appears to be nothing more than an elaborate cultivation of his animal nature. Since everything is within his experience and he is an end in himself with all the implications of his divine I, he may rid himself of corrupting conditions or turn them to his advantage and enjoy his essential purity.

 

Robert Ardrey prides himself in being a hard-nosed evolutionist; at the same time, he knows very well that scientific salvation is an illusion; furthermore, he confesses that illusions are necessary to the survival of the human race: without them, human beings might as well lie down and die, excepting of course nihilists who enjoy leading meaningless lives. Despite its professional skepticism, its admission that humankind shall forever be unconscious of something or the other or the X, modern science is subject to the romantic fallacy, that pure science and applied technology shall save mankind from one evil or another: particularly, all the things we fight over, by producing an abundance of them or by eliminating them. We might very well speak of the romantic scientific fallacy.

 

For instance, we hear from an African American that science will eliminate racialist mythology by proving that "race does not exist," or, to the extent that it does exist, that "cumbersome things, such as race, which befuddle humankind today, won't matter. We'll be free to...." After all, "genetic studies and miscegenation keep blurring race distinctions."

 

An article in the December 2003 issue of Scientific American claims that "the DNA distinctions that once existed are vanishing." As the spurious biological differences are dispensed with, the racialist "conspiracy" justifying slavery and racism will likewise vanish. We may not all be gray and making one dollar per hour, but we will progress together however our divisions be cooperatively arranged, perhaps to the stars and beyond, or back to our mutual womb, the African savanna, or, better yet, to the forests much loved by the more peaceful creatures, the gorillas. There we will all be Africans again and drink mother's milk - the melanin factor will be irrelevant.

 

Thus we have a species of the romantic scientific fallacy, that science and its applied technologies such as genetic engineering, nanotechnology, nuclear technology, information technology, and so on will eliminate evil; witness that "genetic engineering is making crops immune from predators, enables costs to produce more milk, grows human ears on mice...." In fine, everything that makes man vicious and miserable, everything that causes his enmity towards enemies will vanish, however those enemies might be defined in contrast to his amity towards his the kind he defines as good. That is, the original good of the original man or god is projected, until all humankind is good or God - nonetheless we must carefully note that 'good' and 'god' are differently rooted and are not synonymous in all minds.

 

If at first we do not succeed together, let us try and try again. We had a good dream; it is an old dream; let us dream it again and try to realize it, but let us keep both sides of the history of our dual nature in mind at all times. Robert Ardrey duly noted, "So far as the amity-enmity complex is concerned, the mentality of the single Germanic tribe under Hitler differed in no way from that of early man or late baboon." The romantic scientific illusion and inflated dreams of universal peace were overblown during the period of prosperity just prior to the Great War and its continuation - this led some pundits to speculate that great expectations of peace cause war. A hundred million or more human beings perished. Educated Nazis scoffed at the notion that there was a substantial biological difference between races, or that the calipers measuring the lengths of heads in Berlin's streets could actually detect a difference between an Aryan and a Jew - nor would tallness and blue-eyedness do. No matter how blurry the difference was, a myth of a superior race was wanted, wherefore one was had and with devastating consequences.

 

That alone might give our African Americans sufficient cause for doubting that any degree of scientific-blurring and "miscegenation" will have much to do with the coming pacification of the globe. They should also take note of the recent high-technology enthusiasm appertaining to the Internet and neo-liberal globalism, and re-read a popular science fiction book from that period:The End of History.

 



Want to review or comment on this article?


Need a FREE Reader Membership?

Reviewed by E Phillips
Reviewed on March 12, 2019
This is a very articulate essay that gives the reader much to ponder. I would not sweep the scientific method into the same heap that contains all the myths and mischief of human thinking. It is, to paraphrase Churchill, the worst pathway to enlightenment...except for all the others. We will likely bring about our own extinction, not because of a romance with science, but in spite of the best efforts of the caring few to bring the knuckle draggers along with them.

Reviewed by Elizabeth Taylor (Reader)
Reviewed on February 28, 2007
ROFL...you make it sound like a good thing. After reading all the BS about "who is black enough" in the race to be president in 2008, "the melanin factor will be irrelevant" sounds even better. Although, those that have the "melanin factor" seem to be the only one's worried about that "melanin."

David, you make everything you write interesting.

Elizabeth


New Articles by David Arthur Walters
article Image
The platform claims its independent journalists are producing "hundreds of millions" of revenue.
02 Substack Interviewed on Political Prejudice
article Image
Includes opinions of Authorsden's Lawrance G. Lux (R.I.P.)
Fascism Loosely Defined for Current Election Showdown
article Image
They are "unfortunately" not able to disclose their method of prioritizing provider content.
01 Interview with Pubisher Substack;s Intelligence
article Image
Abortion is not merely about women's rights.
Anti-Abortion Aborted
article Image
She is dispirited, depressed, her countenance has a deathly pallor.
Is France Doomed?
article Image
The King and the Duke had an appointment with Death on that day
The 1908 Lisbon Assassinations
article Image
The Apostle of French Realism was a Frustrated Romantic
C'est Moi - She could be anybody
article Image
Where is Grendel? What should I write?
The National Beerhall
article Image
Periodic Bonfires of Vanities may save the human soul from gross materialism
Disposing of Luxuries
article Image
Trick or Treaters may be their Treat
Beware of Polar Bears on Halloween
article Image
Nothing indubitably exists
There is Nothing like Nothing
article Image
Includes commentary from Authorsden Roundtable Knight Lawrance Lux RIP
American Fascism and the Bush Administration
article Image
Closeted fascists still secretly believe democracy must go!
Democracy Must Go!
article Image
Beware!
oBJecTiViSt MoNSTeRS
article Image
Response to friendly adversary's identification of communism with fascism
The False Fascist Political/Economic Dichotomy
article Image
Martin Dies, Sr., Martin Dies, Jr., Cactus Jack Garner, and Un-American activities.
Three Texas Congressmen
article Image
I had two really bad habits - driving and smoking.
My Recurring Dreams
article Image
Postcript to Madame Melina from Mister Groundhog
All Men Are Cocks
article Image
The Devil loves the Terrorist Almighty
Stretching Truth for The Terrorist Almighty
article Image
Mr. Groundhog agrees with Authorsden mystic Melina Costello
YAM equals YAM