|
Does Harry Chapin's old song incite police misconduct? Or simply reflect it?
BUMMER
by
JANSEN ESTRUP
Lately I can't seem to get a song out of my head. It is an old song, now, at least 40. Never was very popular like some of Harry Chapin's others; Cats in the Craddle, Taxi, Road to Kingdom Come, a few others. This one is called Bummer and like most of this brilliant singer/song writer's work, had a driving, hard anger in it, splattered against an orchestral backing.
The recent rash of cop killings forces me to remember it, but the killing of Blacks by cops was hardly new even back then. It is a story (9 minutes), a long story about a short life. Counter-weight to Elvis' In the Ghetto which did receive wide play and can still be heard on 'Oldies' stations, Bummer is too graphic and real. To me, it seems too prophetic as well. The refrain goes ...
"... And just like the man from the precinct said/Put him away, you better kill him instead/A Bummer like that is better off dead/Someday they're gonna have to put a bullet in his head/"
I wonder whether for a segment of law enforcement officials this stanza has become a subconscious mandate, perhaps even a conscious impulse. Citizenry's force, "Our gang", the police, must be ever vigilant against those other gangs, even while they clasp them as essential for their very existence. Without crime, who would need enforcement or even laws? Or do we make law knowing, expecting it to be broken so that this symbiotic relationship can persist, even grow.
And surely he would have to be way beyond recruitment into our prison industrial system in order to be classified "kill 'im instead". Chapin's protagonist 'had the damned good fortune to get drafted' but with no draft, incarceration seems his modern brothers' best option. He wouldn't get paid as well as he did in the Vietnam era armed forces, but his 'enlistment' might be longer. His 'job security' would have been better, but any hopes for a suitable retirement from the military or post office would be out of the question. So would unimportant responsibilities like voting and office holding.
I don't imagine there is a conspiracy, that a piece of Chapin's song is some secret anthem for a rogue police underground, or even that anyone has listened to the song lately. After all, there is only one entry of it on Youtube. And yet, THIS JUST IN ... a Florida police force has just been busted for using the 'mug shots' of Black men as targets at its pistol range.
Maybe it is only that if one lives long enough, everything starts recycling. Ideas, fashions, hobbies, politics ... all have new twists, slick slogans and glossy covers, but is there really any difference between a sock hop and a rave, a stock market crash and a bank robbery, a police action and a surge? A matter of degree, perhaps, but the effects are the same. Youngsters redline their juices, countless poor working stiffs lose their savings, the dead lie silent under waving flags.
|
|
Ads which emphasize the social work angle of society are not nearly as likely to elicit applications. Consequently, of the incidence of shootings and other violence against unarmed, non-violent citizens is far greater than any other nation. In 2003, nearly 460 were killed and many others wounded. Of that reporting, believed to be only half of the actual number, some 240 were mentally ill. Chicago police alone kill more about 50 suspects a year, three-quarters of them Black. Great Britain's bobbies, by contrast, killed no one.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IF1_HZjbXos
Our current corporate prison and justice system is geared to profit for lawyers and prison companies. With all the "wars" on nonviolent crimes, many are put in the system for a minor offense and come out hardened criminals with few other options. I personally know of two cases of wrongful convictions and it makes me sick what has happened to these good people because of perception, not reality.
With most work requiring conviction screening, people coming out of prison have little choice these days. Minimum-wage jobs for those that were growing up with basketball stars and rap legends as heroes, finding college unaffordable, quick buck schemes are much more attractive than the drudgery of 40 hour monotony.
As far as police are concerned, perhaps 95% are good and well meaning people. Unfortunately, during an adrenaline filled chase situation or the perception of a weapon about to be used, often brings out the worst and a lack of judgment that haunts the four police officer who did it for the rest of his or her life. We all have a tendency to join our buddies in mayhem, even if we regret it later. There's also the human nature of protecting a buddy even if they did something very wrong. Like you wrote… It's our gang against their gang. Which gang is better?
Ron