Much of the credit for that goes to the writer/director and the leading lady who both have personal experience with eating disorders. Although there’s plenty of heavy drama here, the movie also includes a bit of humor -- and a romance.
I applaud everyone connected with To the Bone for their courage in bringing attention to eating disorders in such a powerful way. However, this is not a film that’s easy to watch. I admit to closing my eyes during a couple of scenes.
Don’t judge the girl who can’t eat food
without feeling that she’s no good.
No matter how much weight she’s shed,
that feeling stays within her head.
Calories and how to burn them
consume her life. Now she’s a stem.
Worried family and harsh looks
do not end up as the best hooks.
Lily Collins plays this sad girl.
She comes across just like a pearl
who’s hiding in an oyster shell
afraid to emerge and be well.
But doc Keanu Reeves is here.
Will his treatment remove her fear?
To the Bone reveals all of this
in a raw movie not to miss.
Marni Noxon (Buffy the Vampire Slayer) wrote and directed To the Bone. She obviously drew on her own painful experience to tell the story of Ellen, portrayed by Lily Collins. I was completely surprised by Collins’ terrific performance here. I loved her as Snow White in the whimsical Mirror/Mirror but had no idea about the depth of her acting talent. She draws us into her dreary world with a frail look that makes us worry about Ellen immediately. And she seals the deal with her soulful eyes and pessimistic attitude, which seem to hide Ellen’s will to live. We soon learn about the guilt she feels concerning a tragic incident relating to her dark artistic efforts.
Together, Noxon and Collins made sure viewers would be watching something special. Keanu Reeves (John Wick) ably assists them with his gentle turn as William Beckham, a doctor who tries to help his patients understand their eating disorders. He uses a group home environment where the members earn privileges through a point system. They have group meetings, individual therapy, and family meetings.
Most of the film’s key scenes take place in the group home where we get to see patients at different stages of their treatment. This is where Ellen meets witty Luke (Tony winner Alex Sharp), the only male in residence. And, of course, she and Luke develop feelings for each other, but it’s a rocky relationship, for sure.
In Ellen’s case, most of her family has given up on her – and we never even see her father. Real mom (Lily Taylor/The Conjuring) lives in a different town, so stepmom (Carrie Preston/The Good Wife) seems to be in charge. Ellen’s stepsister (played beautifully by Lianna Liberato/The Last Sin Eater) is the only one very close to Ellen. Will this dysfunctional family come together to help her?
My poem above advises us not to judge Ellen, but To the Bone leaves us with the additional message not to judge her family either. It’s a very compassionate, non-judgmental film – one that should have an important impact on people with eating disorders and on their loved ones.
(Released by Netflix and rated TV-MA.)
Review also posted at ReelTalk Movie Reviews.
I always enjoy reading your reviews
m
The danger during this time of trying to determine where one fits is the tendency to join a cult, whether it be religious, drugs, music, gaming, sport, eating disorder, or ISIS, to belong and have an identity… Often quite different from parents and even siblings. No one wants to be "normal" or average. We seek to be exceptional and sometimes, the more different, the better.
I haven't seen the film, but I just read a short story in the latest Playboy about a wealthy family with two young daughters. The youngest daughter is called back home from college (as far away from home--film industry family in LA--as possible) by her four year older sister. She finds her father on life support in the hospital, her mother on life support for another ailment in the same hospital, and her sister, wasting away from anorexia. When the hospital refuses to allow her parents to die at high cost, she brings them home with 24 hour a day nursing care. The day she learns of her sister's death from malnutrition and starvation, the power goes out long enough so that the batteries go down and life support for her parents ends. I think I would like to see that movie, as sad as it is.
Anorexia and bulimia, made famous by the likes of Princess Diana, and many other celebrities, is a cultural epidemic that we need to come to grips with. Giving everyone a sense of self-worth or just be who they are would go a long way. My sister just lost 45 pounds doing alternate day fasting. She says that she has 55 pounds more to go. I'm opting for smaller portions to lose about 20 pounds. I wish I could exercise it off and eat more, but I can't.
Ron