Dispatch from the Heartland
Slinging Insults at the American Viewer
Advertising used to flatter the public. It used to tell us we were smart, discerning, and worthy of good products. But somewhere along the line, a new breed of commercial has emerged — one that treats the viewer not as a customer, but as a target. A target for mockery, for correction, indeed for humiliation even. And nowhere is this trend more perfectly embodied than in the recent ads produced by Sling a live TV streaming service launched in 2015 by DISH Network as the first major live‑TV streaming platform, designed to disrupt traditional cable.
Sling has created a new genre of advertising: the humiliation commercial. Not satire, not cleverness, not self‑aware humor — but a steady drip of contempt aimed directly at the people who fund the company’s existence. These are ads we pay for, ads we are forced to watch, ads that interrupt the very content we subscribe to. And Sling’s creative team seems convinced that the best way to win our loyalty is to portray us as hapless, dim‑witted, boldly confronted and easily corrected.
Consider their earlier masterpiece, the infamous newspaper‑boy commercial. A cheerful kid pedals through a suburban neighborhood delivering newspapers — a symbol of honest work and early‑morning responsibility. Sling’s portrayal of the public? Grown adults hurling newspapers back at him, pelting the poor kid until he’s knocked off his bicycle. The message is unmistakable: the public is irrational, cruel, and stupid — and Sling approves. This is not humor. This is contempt dressed up as marketing.
But Sling was not finished insulting us. Their latest ad doubles down on the condescension. A group of citizens sits on wooden benches in a field, raising their hands like chastened schoolchildren. Each one sheepishly confesses a desire: “I wish I could watch national news.” A desire so basic that every TV platform in America already provides it. Yet Sling treats this person as though he has just asked whether fire is hot. A moderator waves a hand and barks the catchphrase: “Sling lets you do that!”
Then comes the pièce de résistance — a woman dressed in a dark green man’s suit of course with a microphone entering from the right, announcing that the well-wishing man has “embarrassed himself” by asking for something Sling already offers. The voice‑over swoops in like a judge delivering a sentence: “National news for a great price — $19.99. Sling lets you do that.” The viewer is cast as timid, uninformed, and pathetically childish. And Sling expects us to reward this humiliation with a subscription.
This is the new advertising logic: mock the customer, shame the customer, belittle the customer — and assume the customer will buy the product anyway. It is the corporate equivalent of slapping someone across the face and then asking them to sign up for monthly billing.
What Sling and its ad agency fail to understand is simple: people do not enjoy being portrayed as docile, pliable, flat‑headed creatures who need a streaming service to correct their ignorance. People do not enjoy being scolded by moderators, mocked by roving commentators, or portrayed as fools in front of millions of viewers. Advertising is supposed to persuade, not degrade.
Yet this is the direction modern advertising has taken — contempt as a marketing strategy. The public pays for these ads. We fund them. We subsidize them. We endure them. And Sling, in its infinite corporate wisdom, believes the best way to thank us is to portray us as idiots. I would prefer not to. But the ads keep coming. We have to keep watching. We keep paying. And somewhere in a conference room, an ad executive is congratulating himself for another commercial that insults the very people he hopes will subscribe to their services. Perhaps we should call our age the Age of Irony.
My problem is with political ads, especially, attack ads. Surveys have found that they have little affect on the way that people vote. But we are bombarded by them on almost every channel. The parties seem to need continual fundraising to pay for all that television time that doesn't really benefit candidates at all.
It's a crazy world and there's a crazy new idea every day being thrust upon us.
Ron