This's the second letter in full by Eric Mottram in Gröningen, Netherlands, where he was Professor of English, from 1955 to 1961, addressed to T. Wignesan in West Berlin, together with a poem entitled "Lecture in the Cave".
(I have not seen this poem published elsewhere and Eric's handwriting being what it was, I can't be certain of the "spelling" of some words: I stand to be corrected, though, by those who know better.)
A-weg 39,
Gröningen,
Netherlands
February 4, 1958
Dear Wignesan,
I’m very glad indeed that you like living in Berlin, and you sound as though you are at last getting something done and being reasonably content.
I suppose you think I’ve been rude in not replying to your letter until now: frankly, I felt mad at you for one thing and another and could not bring myself
to write. It’s my fault, not yours. Anyway you can think that if you like. Of course I’ll read your poems « in their present reformed condition », as you put it,
any time you like: you don’t have to ask. But you must not expect dishonest praise. As for your coming to Gröningen, I was right: my landlord has been
forced to fill up his spare room by some new regulations about Dutch householders taking in Indonesian refugees. So that’s that, and in any case, I’m
so buried in work that I couldn’t think of looking after anyone at the moment. The thought of having to put up with your arguments for more than one hour
fills me with panic, I may add. I’m beginning to see how intolerant and emotional I am, and I don’t like it. So let me do penance by reading your revised
poems !
Incidentally, going to Berlin, as you suggested, last Christmas, was quite out of the question: I had to see my family, actually, and later attended a
dying friend in the Isle of Wight. I should like to see Berlin, but I can’t see why you say I « can’t afford to miss » it. From what I’ve heard, it is a fascinating
place for those with money or a taste for vice and culture. You must tell me what it is really like. On the whole I am not very fond of modern Germans
and their ways and utterances.
I wonder if you have managed in Berlin to come across a prize-winning Indian film called « Pather Panchali »: it is undoubtedly a masterpiece by any
standards. The director is a young man named Sanjyit (Satyajit) Ray: it’s his first film, astonishingly enough.
I envy you (in) Berlin, being free to work when you like, plunging into philosophy, writing your poems (whatever I may think of them). I lead a very tied
existence for no good reason I sometimes think. My poems lie in a folder unfinished, like all my other creative writing: a pity, this. I think the time has come
for another move, a change, in my life: I’ve been still for three years. Here’s a poem - unrevized - on lecturing: it’s as good a subject as any: and it’s
called the Lecture in the Cave.
Best wishes.
Eric Mottram
LECTURE IN THE CAVE
If words of mine act in their nests of beaks to drown,
How should they know what pressure underlies the drumhead skin ?
Notions crack across their willing two-backed tustling hours:
Some druid (dried) sightless but for propitiating manic seats
Will expose Marsyas or avenge Eurydice’s betrayed Lord on dolmens
Erected under murderous insistence. Ought I then to walk the stage,
Ignore its resinous creaks, just pour the hairy longings
In shoals of hot molasses for the pails they queue with,
Negro knuckles reflecting their inturned eyes which shutter
Everything except the centaur’s cloven words their ears receive,
And panic, wordly transmissions Chiron batters down their pores ?
I make a cave of sunlit wilderness, a guano hoard of rich dimness.
Meanwhile with hooves well manicured, deceiving the important few,
Shanks well shagged and legs in four-time steadily ramming the course,
I hold my manic head erect above the stall and speak where neighing
Might attract attention to what bestial parts and trampling horn are saying.
Prince, since it is written you must act the beast, parade the Shaman, wag the Slaver’s tongue,
Let a guru maim your confidence, mine apologetics with a breach unslung.
(c) T. Wignesan -Paris, 1958-2023
Want to review or comment on this poem?
Need a FREE Reader Membership?
Reviews of "Eric Mottram's letter and poem from Gröningen to Wignesan in Berlin,4/2/58"
I have read Eric's poem and it reads like what I have called my "nonsense" poems. Merely strings of words that go together well in the poet's mind, but cannot be interpreted except by those steeped in this kind of very abstract poetry, similar to paintings or music that also have no other purpose than insider critical review.
The essence of greatness is communicating something. The letter he wrote to you communicated well. Maybe just a thought or line is an epic poem. But if the poet only writes to his or her own ego or ardent followers, what good is it?
Based on his poem, I would hate to attend one of his off-the-wall, in the cave, lectures. Going away from the lecture shaking my head and saying to myself, another hour listening to an idiot rant and waste my time.
This is a book of free verse poetry that addresses the seven main tests in life and offers some sensible solutions to passing those tests with minimal discomfort.
This is a book of free verse poetry that addresses the seven main tests in life and offers some sensible solutions to passing those tests with minimal discomfort.
All power to your words! Best. TW
The essence of greatness is communicating something. The letter he wrote to you communicated well. Maybe just a thought or line is an epic poem. But if the poet only writes to his or her own ego or ardent followers, what good is it?
Based on his poem, I would hate to attend one of his off-the-wall, in the cave, lectures. Going away from the lecture shaking my head and saying to myself, another hour listening to an idiot rant and waste my time.
Ron