Moral Dilemma – Cats and Birds
by Erin Elizabeth Kelly-Moen — Read all 1,670 poems by Erin Elizabeth Kelly-Moen
Monday, October 10, 2005
The day started out lovely, late summer in Arizona,
had been deliciously fraught with clouds, muting
desert sun’s inferno smile. Around dawn, a brief
cloudburst brought delight to ears, eyes and mind.
A school day, but, first, a quick trip to the front porch
to sit on a black widow-webbed chair.
Three of the seven cats out front, and only moments
had passed when I noticed a bird-in-mouth. Cats
have been around practically all my life, though,
usually one at a time. I remember rescuing a mouse
from the family cat at a young age, holding it by
the tip of its tail to deposit it somewhere safely.
And, I saw it climb its body, and then its tail,
to bite me! There is a soul-shock that comes
when what we righteously rescue bites us in
panic and moot ignorance.
I couldn’t help myself, I jerked my hand away
from the mouse’s teeth, and it went flying,
never to be seen, again. So started my crusade
of saving prey from cats.
Anyway, I jumped up, grabbed Bug by the scruff,
and took the bird from his mouth. I saw it was
an Aztec Dove, the smallest gem of our desert doves.
I ran into the house yelling for my daughter
to come help, and rushed out back to the divided
rabbit pen. She opened the top, and I placed the dove
inside the unoccupied side. It was in shock, and
lie there, limp but breathing. One wing was
awkwardly skewed, and a leg, up in the feathers,
was bleeding slightly. There are differences in degrees
of injuries cats inflict, and I wasn’t sure how badly
the bird was hurt.
Over the next hour, I got the girls ready and off to school,
checking on the bird occasionally. He stayed dazed
for the next couple of hours. Finally, mid-morning,
its eyes were bright and its demeanor alert. Cats
hovered under and to the side of the wire pen, causing
the dove to move around the cage, producing
a stronger flow of blood from its wounded leg.
I saw I had created a ‘no-win situation’,
wondered if I should give the dove back to the cats,
knew I couldn’t, but I also knew the bird was dying,
possibly in great pain. When prey is caught by a predator,
they go into a type of shock and don’t feel pain
as they are dying. Their eyes get a dulled, hopeless look,
and they try to escape more by reflex than awareness.
So the day went. Every time I checked on the dove,
there was a cat or several eye-balling its half dead essence.
It disturbed me, and I kept thinking I should have left
the small dove to its cat-fate…
I went to pick up my youngest daughter from school
at 3:00 pm, showed her the dove, which was still alive.
A half hour later, it was dead, on its back, by the bowl
of water and a jar lid of birdseed I had
placed in the cage earlier.
And, a cat sat underneath the pen,
watching the dead bird…
Erin Elizabeth Kelly-Moen
© Copyright 10/3/05
This is so like you to try to save everything! What a gentle soul you have...you won't even kill a bug! I am so sorry the bird died, but I admire your valiant effort...Love ya,
Lori
I would have done the same thing. One solution, keeping the cats indoors. That's what we did...that way it couldn't happen. Now, if the cats wanted to kill mice, I had no problem with that, but a bird...that would have devastated me.
Excellent, emotive piece, and thank you for trying.
(((HUGS))) and love, Karla. :(
My son brought a monkey home that was trapped in a tree they chopped down...he was slightly hurt on his elbow!! My son said to me he never knew monkeys did not have hands on their front legs...I gave him a funny look and said...MY GOD he musta lost his hands aswell when the tree came down....so I took a closer look...there was no blood to be seen, Only two blackish spots where the hands was suppose to be...I am not sure now if this animal was born without hands or did he losse it in a accident he had before!! He is quite happy and eats like a pig...and handles anything with those handless fore-arms!!
Love Tinka
Stephanie -- a bird lover from the word GO ..... I would have done the same thing.
I once had somewhat similar experience, but was not due to a cat. We've once found a pigeon lying hurt on the road. It looked like it could have been struck or run over by a car. I picked it up and took it home, wanting to take it to the vet, but found that we could not afford to do so during that time of our lives. I was heartbroken to see it was suffer. I put it in a box, but felt so helpless to ease its pain. I stroke it head and its feathers until it closed it eyes about what seemed an eternity hour. Then we buried it in the yard.
My hubby said that it probably had died in peace, knowing that someone was stroking its head gently and standing beside it. What my hubby said had made me feel so much better about its tragedy.
Perhaps taking the dove to a cat-free environment where it can't see the cats would have been a better choice.
Sandie May Angel a.k.a. Sandie Angel :o(