I wrote this in a few minutes as a first draft to work on in a collaboration with a fellow poet (one that I admire greatly). He told me that it was good enough to stand on its own. I thought I'd work on it more but I haven't been able to. I thought I'd post it and ask for the opinon of others. I don't think it is a poem as much as a collection of thoughts. Please suggest changes openly. Thanks
i enjoyed it as well
breaking down of the sentences so that we could savor
the reading so it would lastlonger on the minds....other than that i think it can and do stand on its own(with me it is always interesting to see what else can be said or done with the same words) sometimes i mixed two pieces together so it would be interesting to see what another person could bring to this
*it does has enuf grace and beauty to stand alone
Reviewed by Katy Walsvik (Reader)
Reviewed on February 20, 2005
The last two lines have impact and bring this poetic, imaginative 'commentary' to the sort of close that will linger...
Now... since you asked, Chanti, I would delete the 2nd line. I tend not to presume to interfere with someone elses creative process but if you sincerely wish to know, that's a change I would make. (You're very brave... grin).
I reiterate, though, this is a "feast" for the head. katy xox.
Chanti, I will tell you pretty much what I tell all that ask for help in developing a poem or story...Has what you written so far satisfied your "hunger" for this particular poem...? Or do you feel an urge to continue in your quest for more poetic "meat"...? It is YOU that ultimately makes the decision as to how good or bad or how long or short a poem has to be...so far with this I am made to be hungry, so I would assume I got something out of it, but then again ANY free food & I am up and ready to eat...! LOL! Peace, Ed & Rufuz
I see no place for corrections, Chanti, this is perfect and your message addressed completely and clearly. Nice job. I agree with your friend, this stands alone on its own merit.
Take care,
Sherry
You have done an excellant job chanti and the only suggestiong I might add is when youend it with there is no second course perhaps the second course could be what awaits us on the other side as our dessert. As we say though it is a matter of taste, and your ending is just as applicable.
This is superb and it does stand on its own as your friend said.It is a gourmet feast with a wisdom message. The only thing I would change is the placement removing the &:
Life is bitter sweet and not always kind to the palette...but this is very pleasing be it a collection of thoughts or not. I don't know if 'gulped' quite works, may I suggest swollowed...I personaly would drop the second life and change the wording slightly so it read
'but unlike dinning
offers no second courses.'
That's just me though, This is a fine piece of work Chanti (chuck)...
and rightly stands on it's own as a poem.
That small wriggly creature, nunu aka Paul;-}
Reviewed by Judy Lloyd (Reader)
Reviewed on February 17, 2005
I agree this stands on its own and it is a lot like that beautiful still life you have in the background.
I was savoring this morsel of a poem (so true, so true)until the last line. More explanation, please? If it means what I think it means, I'm going to cry! It has too! I know that at the moment I'm just too obtuse to catch your meaning...
I would not presume (though I have asked the same of others here)to offer changes...I learn every day. Like Ed told me, he just knows what he likes. Thats me as well. If it moves me, or makes me think, or to see our lives from another angle, then to me, it is good. This poem is very good, and I thought, creative.
Reviewed by Jerry Bolton (Reader)
Reviewed on February 17, 2005
It is good, no doubt about it, a few changes would make it even more interesting. I have always tried to write free-style with an eye for staying away from the "just one long sentence broken into many lines" way so many write. To me, if you are capable of breaking up the "long sentence" trap and make the poem a collabration of disjointed lines that nonetheless carry the message, then you have a fine poem. I hope I articulated my view coherently.
A wonderful delicious feast you have prepared for us Chanti! Might I suggest a slight change?
Replace 'turned away with distaste', with 'rejected in distaste' to clarify the point that life should not be held in low esteem, but we should celebrate the sanctity of it.
Dear readers, this is my third book of poems, and inside are a special collection of what have turned out to be not only MY personal favorites, but also the favorites of many of YOU. Some of these have never been available in print before...
A people’s heart can be found in their poetic words. In history men and women have stood firmly upon their soapboxes and street corners, rallying the deepest beliefs of people to rise up and be heard. The poetrypages.com has offered that voice a new
breaking down of the sentences so that we could savor
the reading so it would lastlonger on the minds....other than that i think it can and do stand on its own(with me it is always interesting to see what else can be said or done with the same words) sometimes i mixed two pieces together so it would be interesting to see what another person could bring to this
*it does has enuf grace and beauty to stand alone
Now... since you asked, Chanti, I would delete the 2nd line. I tend not to presume to interfere with someone elses creative process but if you sincerely wish to know, that's a change I would make. (You're very brave... grin).
I reiterate, though, this is a "feast" for the head. katy xox.
Since you asked, here's one penny of my two cents.
Change lines 3 and 4 to
Each mouthful taken sensuously
and eaten with passion
Or at least I guess that's what I write.
I think it's quite beautiful.
with Ant on the last line.
All in all, a beautiful piece, deserving to be served all by itself,
with no help from anyone else.
This is one great poem...and I cannot see any reason to inrich it!!
Love Tinka
I might change to opening line to read:
Life should be savoured
as a gourmet delicacy...
Also, you might incorporate a few more "food" words such as:
tidbits, morsels, and such.
Hugs,
Tami
Take care,
Sherry
Great stuff,
Felix
each mouthful taken sensuously
eaten with passion
'but unlike dinning
offers no second courses.'
That's just me though, This is a fine piece of work Chanti (chuck)...
and rightly stands on it's own as a poem.
That small wriggly creature, nunu aka Paul;-}
Replace 'turned away with distaste', with 'rejected in distaste' to clarify the point that life should not be held in low esteem, but we should celebrate the sanctity of it.
Love the last line!